Your overrated XI

He is over rated on here. Made regular mistakes for us.

Won the golden gloves for conceding the least amount of goals a few times too!

Take your pick.

Won the golden gloves for conceding the least amount of goals a few times too!

Take your pick.

He won them before he started going down hill.

He won them before he started going down hill.

Bit different from being overrated then!

Code: [Select]

Cech
Alves - Terry - Luiz - Alba
Arteta
Wilshere - Carrick
Januzaj - Neymar - Messi

Controversial, but so what.

Jessica Alba at left back is a bit of a bold call

Some good shouts in here and some real head scratchers.....not sure how Reina is overrated. Can't find a team that wants him right now and he's still a quality keeper. That screams underrated to me all day long.


Not sure who said it above but overrated doesn't mean bad, it just means there is too much hype for their actual level of performance.

For me the list probably begins with Luiz. 50m??? Are you kidding me?


Some others off the top of my head:
Terry
Rooney
Cavani
Fabregas
Ramos
Alves
Benzema
Higuain
Ribery
Fellaini (and that's saying something because most agree he's worthless to begin with)
Ochoa for keeper.....he had a good world cup but he's not that good....

Purely based upon the Premier League

Hart
Smalling
Jones
Mertasacker
Baines
Cleverly
Wilshire
Janujzi
Podolski
Rooney
Costa

Code: [Select]

Cech
Alves - Terry - Luiz - Alba
Arteta
Wilshere - Carrick
Januzaj - Neymar - Messi

Controversial, but so what.

Jesus Christ, Res.

Alves, Arteta, Wilshere and Luiz I agree.

Seeing Reina in overrated threads upsets me. Him being understudy to Mig will upset me more though. Thought he was class for Napoli last year

Seeing Reina in overrated threads upsets me. Him being understudy to Mig will upset me more though. Thought he was class for Napoli last year

Ridiculous to call him overrated given the brilliant service he provided to us. That said, it doesn't take away the fact that he had a relatively poor 2011-2012 and 2012-2013.

Ridiculous to call him overrated given the brilliant service he provided to us. That said, it doesn't take away the fact that he had a relatively poor 2011-2012 and 2012-2013.

Definitely. He is still a top class keeper, he has been poor in the last 2 years because frankly speaking as a TEAM we have been poor as well, so to single out Reina is harsh. He also had no confidence in the backfour in front of him like he did when he had players like Carragher & Hyypia.

Him being understudy to Mig will upset me more though.

I wouldn't get too upset mate.