Relative to other clubs? I think we did rather well, let's have a look at our competitors.
- IIkay Gundogan
- Leroy Sane
- Henrikh Mkhitaryan
- Granit Xhaka
. I'm happy with our transfer business. Klopp got the players he wanted and they all suit his style of play. Klavan did well in pre-season, Grujic looks a very exciting young prospect, Mané has arguably been our best player in pre-season. Jury still out on Matip, Karius and Wijnaldum.
c. How big of a clearout did you expect?
we've had a full pre-season with Klopp and we've got a young, hungry squad.
Not the first year we have had it, and if it was anyone else in charge, we would be complaining about the lack of experienced and star players we have signed.
I'm sure all the players we've signed are players Klopp wants, but the 4 names I've left from your list above are all players he has worked with, or knows very well, and were the kind of players we were told he was the man we needed to get them to sign up. Instead they haven't, and as I predicted, the lack of European football was obviously a significant reason why they didn't.
I've not seen much of pre season bar a few highlights on SSN, and I wouldn't put much emphasis on the results, but its never ideal to go into the season on the back of a loss, and certainly not on the scoreline it was, as any momentum from the Barcelona result was instantly lost.
Of the players we have signed, the majority of them are either unproven foreigners we've never heard of, or domestic players at inflated fees. In many ways, a mere continuation of FSG's long established transfer policy, and we know how that has worked. I really fear Mane could be another Benteke, and Wijnaldum has never pulled up many trees before. For the best part of €75m, I just hope they're worth it, but I have my reservations. The rest are players of the calibre you would expect Rodgers to secure tbh. On the clear out, I thought the Smith transfer was a surprise, and the Allen one was a shock, as he was possibly the most improved player under Klopp, while someone in their wisdom decided not to offer Toure a new deal.
Personally, I'm very upset we're not in Europe at all, and there's no question it's severely impacted our activity in the transfer market. So I think talk of winning the league is just fantasy football. We didn't qualify for Europe in 2011, it was no advantage whatsoever the following year, and I think this season will mirror that one, a few highlights, a lot of mediocrity, and a modest league finish as a result. And as Kenny did, Klopp will have to face tough questions if that is what transpires again.