I'm not a fan of zonal marking. We don't conceed many goals as Reina's great record proves but that doesn't mean zonal marking works.
It doesn't show how many saves Reina makes from set pieces or how many free headers go over the bar or how many of the set pieces hit the first man. The goals we tend to conceed come by and large from set pieces. But it's the system we use and we're gonna keep using it so there's no point in complaining about it.
I used to think exactly as you do but I have lately started to think "zonal" is the better system. The big problem with man-for-man, I think, is that the central defenders can get dragged well out of position if they have to stay with one player so big holes can open up and these can be a problem if the first ball isn't cleared. Then you might have strikers or wingers following back marking someone and thus becoming the prime defence. Unless I am not understanding it all correctly, which is eminently possible.
That's how I see it now anyway, though I reserve the right to change my mind again anytime soon.
Logged