Age is a big factor in this debate, Alonso is 28 and £32 Million for him is a brilliant offer. (Of course id rather him stay). Mascherano is about 25 and in my opinion the best defensive midfeilder in the world, which makes him tougher for him to be replaced.
Looking not just as this season but at the future 4 or 5 seasons aswell, the sensible sale would be Alonso, out of the two of them.
Logged