PFA Awards 2009

5 Man United players, 1 Liverpool player, no Torres, no Alonso, No Frank Lampard??? What a joke!! 

Considering there are 5 mancs in this list, won't everybody at United have to vote for Gerrard seeing as they can't vote for their own?

! Good Point!!

Considering there are 5 mancs in this list, won't everybody at United have to vote for Gerrard seeing as they can't vote for their own?

Haha! Very very good point that actually!

Considering there are 5 mancs in this list, won't everybody at United have to vote for Gerrard seeing as they can't vote for their own?

Well spotted mate.

If I'm not mistaken didn't Ginola win in 99 when there were plenty of United players up for it too?

When I heard this to day I was almost lost for words. If anyone thinks that Giggs, Van Der Sar or Ronaldo are worthy of Player Of The Year then they know nothing about football.

An absolute joke.

PFA Players' Player of the Year contenders:

Rio Ferdinand - Manchester United Frank Lampard - Chelsea
Steven Gerrard - Liverpool
Ryan Giggs - Manchester United Ashley Young - Aston Villa
Cristiano Ronaldo - Manchester United
Edwin van der Sar - Manchester United Xabi Alonso - Liverpool
Nemanja Vidic - Manchester United

PFA Young Player of the Year contenders:

Gabriel Agbonlahor - Aston Villa
Jonny Evans - Manchester United Emiliano Insua - Liverpool
Stephen Ireland - Manchester City
Aaron Lennon - Tottenham Hotspur
Rafael - Manchester United
Ashley Young - Aston Villa

- - - - - - - -  - - - - - -

Thats a bit better now

Should be:

Gerrard
Lampard
Alonso
Vidic
Schwarzer
Hangeland

Should be:

Gerrard
Lampard
Alonso
Vidic
Schwarzer
Hangeland

If I were to compile a list it would actually be exactly the same! Maybe Hangeland wouldn't quite cut it.

Bollocks that, Xabi should be on it!

2 Fulham players is a bit much, they been good but not that good tbh. But 5 united... Giggs traditional place on the list is really pissing me of now tbh

Ronaldo? no way all hes done all season is moan,moan,dive,moan

Gerrard
Lampard
Young
Vidic
Ronaldo
Hangeland

Giggs? Piss take knobs. It should be between Gerrard and Lampard, easily.

Giggs? Piss take knobs. It should be between Gerrard and Lampard, easily.

No, It should just be Gerrard actually.

I will admit Giggs has been good this season for a guy who is 100 years old but honestly a player who what started 11 games this season should be top 6 players in the Premiership, give me a break. Some others I can understand but can be debatable like Rio and Van Der Saar because of that great record in terms of not giving up goals but to be  at the bare minimum you should be a starter for you club to be considered, not a squad player and the same goes with the young player away as well with Evans who started 11 and Rafael started 9.

vidic-the player that got played by torres.
ferdinand-awful against liverpool
giggs-played bit-part this season but still got the nomination
van der sar-crap when at fulham, still crap at man utd

the list should be like this

ronaldo
gerrard
anelka
mascherano
alonso
geovanni (he's better compared to giggs, rio, van der sar combined)

Looking good, Poll from SkySports web site.

poll doesn't mean anything...i wonder if man utd scums even played like sh*t they still got nominated...

What did Ferdinand do to be there?
And even though Giggs have played been there for every premier league season.... PFA player of the year is for player of the year a.k.a. the one who played well in that year and not over 10 years.

Should be
Gerrard - every year
Ronaldo - only because he is Player of the Year
Lampard - topsy turvy season but quite consistent
Alonso - reminds us of his 2004-7 self
van der sar - well for that 14 clean sheets in a row
Vidic - don't know why but everyone seem to say he's gonna win

Young player
Insua - pretty good huh? I think he has impressed as much or if not more than Rafael
Ireland - arrival of Robinho but the player they didn't pay a penny for is the star
Ashley Young - pretty impressive till December
Aaron Lennon - always rated this guy
Mark Noble ?
Evans ?

But I still think Stevie should get it ahead of anyone.

Good nominations but again, Denilson should definately be in young player of the season.

This list is shocking!

The FA must bury her head in shame

FA - Ferguson's Assistants!

What did Ferdinand do to be there?
And even though Giggs have played been there for every premier league season.... PFA player of the year is for player of the year a.k.a. the one who played well in that year and not over 10 years.

Should be
Gerrard - every year
Ronaldo - only because he is Player of the Year
Lampard - topsy turvy season but quite consistent
Alonso - reminds us of his 2004-7 self
van der sar - well for that 14 clean sheets in a row
Vidic - don't know why but everyone seem to say he's gonna win

Young player
Insua - pretty good huh? I think he has impressed as much or if not more than Rafael
Ireland - arrival of Robinho but the player they didn't pay a penny for is the star
Ashley Young - pretty impressive till December
Aaron Lennon - always rated this guy
Mark Noble ?
Evans ?

But I still think Stevie should get it ahead of anyone.

I like your Player of the year award list and it would be pretty much the way I see it. As far as the young player of the year as much as Insua has done well he played what 7 games in the league. He would be lucky now to get 10 and qualify to get a medal if indeed we won the league. My list would be something like

Young
Agbonlahor
Lennon
Nasri
Mikel
Ireland

I think the PFA nominations are a disgrace! 5 players from Man Utd? If ever you needed any more proof of arse licking in your life. Obviously I agree with Gerrard, even take away any bias, anyone can see he has had a fab season. But sorry Giggs? Ferdninand? Van der Sar? Ok yes their season has been good but plenty more deserving players to take their place. Possibly lampard or terry or what about carragher??

Fergie should have just asked for the Gerrard's spot too: for Paul Scoles!