Reina or Casillas for Spain?

If you were manager of Spain would you pick Reina or Casillas as your no1 choice goalkeeper

If I'm being honest I'd pick Iker Casillas

I think he's the best goalkeeper in the world.

Casillas.

Less chance of Reina getting injured.

Good answer but I mean who do you think is better?

Casillas. Reina sits on the bench making everyone laugh.

If it ain't broke don't fix it - keep Casillas in net.

Plus like JD said, less chance of Pepe getting injured.

Yes but who's a better goalkeeper

If it ain't broke don't fix it - keep Casillas in net.

Plus like JD said, less chance of Pepe getting injured.

If it ain't broke dont Hicks it

Casillas.

Much better hair.

I'll tell you the difference between the two keepers.

Casillas is the luckiest goalkeeper in the world.

Reina is the best goalkeeper in the world.

Casillas.

Short-sleeve 'keeper tops wouldn't suit Reina.

 

Loving the answers

Casillas, but not by much.

Cassilas

Cassilas

Spain found another gem of a player from somewhere have they?

Reina,the clown let in 5 against us.

Cassilas

Not your inner Madridista coming out there is it remad?

I'd hardly call him a clown because he was MOM that night

If it wasn't for him Dossena might have had a hat-trick

Yes but who's a better goalkeeper

Reina

It's a law all goalkeepers have to be a bit crazy, and Pepe is one crazy fella. Plus Pepe would beat Casillas in a fight!

What are you talking about!

You're all forgetting about Victor Valdes! 

What are you talking about!

You're all forgetting about Victor Valdes!  

Manuel Almunia is getting a long overdue call up I heard

Still Iker for me.

Pepe needs time to get practice in for his aeroplane sing songs.

PEPE REINA Camarerooo

Love Pepe.  Such a character!   

I rate both keepers highly and they are definitely top in the world. It's just unlucky that they happen to play for the same national team.

To be brutally honest Casillas is the better keeper at present.

Backed this up at Anfield had it not been him in goal Madrid would have lost 8-0.

Reina - he plays for Liverpool,enough said

Shot stopping Casillas is unparalleled. Distribution, Reina is unparalleled.

Take your pick. I prefer Reina (obv) and wish him all the success in the world, but I don't want him injured.

Would Reina have kept out the first goal against US today? I know its impossible to know really, but wondering whether anyone thinks he would have done a better job?

I think Reina would have done a better job. He has a lot more experience with high pressure, make or break games. Madrid never makes it far enough in the CL to really test Iker and la Liga doesn't come down to the last game of the season.

gee it tough. pepe has to be one the unluckiest keepers ever- just had to be born a similarish time to casillas. Because I'm biased id pick Pepe!