Nemeth Deserves a nod ahead of N'gog?

I am not Rafa and I strongly respect the decisions of the best coach on the planet but I strongly believe that Nemeth is far better than N'gog. Nemeth has all it takes to develop into a quality partner for Torres but Ngog can never partner Torres and would never be a quarter as good. Nemeth drops to midfield and helps to build up play with his classical backheels. What do you think about this fans? YNWA

Nemeth would of got the chance to get a few games in but unlucky for him he got hurt which open the door for Ngog who started slow but got better as he got more experience playing with the first team. Also the fact he went out on loan and first game got hurt which again is the last thing you want when you are trying to break into a team.

I think that,Ngog is better play in front "Target man"

I am not Rafa and I strongly respect the decisions of the best coach on the planet but I strongly believe that Nemeth is far better than N'gog. Nemeth has all it takes to develop into a quality partner for Torres but Ngog can never partner Torres and would never be a quarter as good. Nemeth drops to midfield and helps to build up play with his classical backheels. What do you think about this fans? YNWA

Classical back heels eh. Which symphony are they?

How many times have you watched Ngog play by the way? Personally I'd like them both to be given chances. In pre season.

I've seen a few games with Ngog and I wasn't in particularly impressed with what he had to offer.

Meanwhile, before I'd even heard of David Ngog, I was monitoring how well Nemeth was doing in the reserves.  I think Nemeth has waiting long enough to be given the nod TBH.

As Kenny has said, give them both a good go in pre season.

I think they'll both get their chances in early and late pre season with Torres coming back later than usual. I'm looking forward to seeing how Nemeth fairs with players like Stevie, Kuyt and Torres around him.

Nemeth is a class act.

But you're comparing oranges with apples. Different players, different roles. Maybe Nemeth can be back-up to Gerrard, but Ngog has the attributes to stand in for Torres.

Also, we've only seen Nemeth in the reserves. Ngog has three first team goals, at a good per-minute rate.

Did you see Ngog's reserve game against Newcastle towards the end of last season? He tore them to bits, was superb. But you're comparing what you know about Nemeth from the reserves to what has been seen of Ngog in the first team.

i think that nemeth is a good foward i would like to see him play a bit more in the first team try to blood more youth players into the first team like they have done with darby,spearing,insua  also Daniel Pacheco  was playing some pre season games last term would like to see him a bit more

I believe Nemeth deserves his chance. I've seen some videos of him on youtube(yes, I know they only put the good stuffs in) and he is a good player.

He seems more of a runner than N'gog to me. I can imagine Nemeth racing on to a through ball taking on a defender but I can't imagine that with N'gog.

N'Gog needs to go on loan somewhere in England imo... Give Nemeth his chance

N'Gog needs to goon loan somewhere in England imo

How about the Gooners?

Did you see Ngog's reserve game against Newcastle towards the end of last season?

He was on fire in that game. The gulf in quality was clear to see.

There's been many times Nemeth has been by far the best player on the pitch whilst playing for the reserves in the past. He's a great player in my opinion - seems to have that natural ability.

But I think Ngog has got the edge over him in the sense that Ngog is pretty much in the first team category and Nemeth has been a regular reserve player.

Agreed on them being different types of players, so in that sense it makes them more difficult to compare.

If Nemeth keeps working hard and shows the right attitude on and off the pitch, I think it's only fair he should get a chance this season. But I've got a feeling it wont be at the expense of Ngog.

I would definatley give the lad a few run-outs this season. From what i have seen of him in the reserves which i admit isnt the whole course of the season but a fair few games, he has quality.

Ngog has not exactly set the world alight but he too deserves his chance.

Let's hope they impress !

He 100% does, N'Gog is the biggest waste of space to ever grace the fields on the Tin Mine.

He 100% does, N'Gog is the biggest waste of space to ever grace the fields on the Tin Mine.

This is probably the dumbest post I've read in a while?.. *yawn*..

He 100% does, N'Gog is the biggest waste of space to ever grace the fields on the Tin Mine.

Think he's here on a wind up. A few of his/hers posts have been a bit silly.

Would like to see both Nemeth and Ngog given run out's pre-season, personally speaking Pacheco should be given a chance to come of the bench and see how he get's on in games that we are cruising

Would like to see both Nemeth and Ngog given run out's pre-season, personally speaking Pacheco should be given a chance to come of the bench and see how he get's on in games that we are cruising

Would like to see both Nemeth and Ngog given run out's pre-season, personally speaking Pacheco should be given a chance to come of the bench and see how he get's on in games that we are cruising

would not leave de la valle out of the equation though

N'gog did well last season and he scored goals I think both nemeth and N'gog should play because they both have the potential to be good players in the future

He 100% does, N'Gog is the biggest waste of space to ever grace the fields on the Tin Mine.

This poster needs to be removed from our site immediately. True fans support their players with consideration, not dismiss them out of hand.Ok mods by all means tolerate a few drunken/ill-worded posts, but when the obvious stares you in the face, f*ck them off please.

How about the Gooners?

Just because some of us can't afford real space bars doesn't mean youmakefunofit

Howaboutyougobuyonethen. Tightarse

I think both will get run outs in pre season as both are talented players and given a little time both could become valued squad members. It will only help them and liverpool the more playing time they can get along side Torres and Co