I totally disagree. I grew up watching Gretzky, Lemieux, Messier, Lidstrom, Pavel Bure, Kariya, Bourque etc.. From what I have seen of Crosby and what he has already accomplished, he could break most of Gretzky's records. I also think he is just as good as Lemieux if not better.
He has a lot of work to do to surpass #99 and all his records. If he can stay healthy, and continue playing and have a long career, he will be considered in the same mold as Gretzky. I dont think he could physically break some of the scoring records Gretzky has, but thats only because the game has changed and its just not possible to do so. He is already the best player in the NHL. I would take him over Ovechkin and Sedin. He is easily the best all around player of any player in the league right now.
With all due respect Yank, I think you're way off on this. Gretzky is so far and away the best player that ever played hockey, and probably always will be. Only Mario can even be considered it that arguement. Only other player to have that much effect on hockey was Bobby Orr, as he completely transformed the defense positon.
I know it's a different game now, Gretzky flourished in a wide-open high scoring decade , and Crosby plays in a much, much more tight checking defense first era. Mario got caught kinda in between, as a rookie in 1986 he was in his prime from 88 to about 96 when all the injuries and his illness slowed him considerably. Just think about this, if Gretzky never scored a goal he would STILL be the all-time highest scored based on assists alone.
All those youngest records Crosby has , well he was luckier to start his NHL career about a year earlier than Gretz. Remember Gretz started in the WHA at age 18. Also Gretz never played in the Olympics. I'm sure if pro's were allowed back then he would have won several Gold's. Remember those series with the Russians in the 80's.
Best hockey Ive ever seen in my life was the 3 game series in the 1987 Canada Cup vs USSR. All three games were 6-5 finals , the first two in OT. Gretzky and Lemieux teaming up to beat Russia. One on the greatest moments in hockey history. This was also before there were any Russians in the NHL , and it was an intense rivalry for years with the NHL vs USSR. Ah, I just had to You-Tube it....
Canada Cup 1987, Lemieux goalGives me goosebumps, just listen to how loud that crowd was. It's just not the same anymore.
Aw well, tangent over . Gretzkys numbers are just insane. Even compared to players in his era at such a young age. He completely dominated. Just look at how much better he was than the second best scorers.
GRETZKY
Year Age GP G A PTS *-league leader
79-80 19 79 51 86* 137* Most assists and points. Rookie year
80-81 20 80 55 109* 164* 2nd A was 84, PTS 135
81-82 21 80 92* 120* 212* 2nd G was 64. A 93, PTS 147
82-83 22 80 71* 125* 196* 2nd G 66, A 86, PTS 124. Age 22 won title by 72
83-84 23 74 87* 118* 205* 2nd G 56, A 86, PTS 125. Age 23 .. 80 pt win. (thats 1 a game)
84-85 24 80 73* 135* 208* 2nd G 71, A 84, PTS 135. All 2nd's were teamates
85-86 25 80 52 163* 215* 2nd A 93, PTS 141
Crosby has only won one scoring title , in 06-07 w 120 PTS. And led the league in goals once with 51 in 2010 at age 22. Still very impressive resume. Has had injury problems, but still no where near as dominant as Gretzky. There's even a fair argument that he's not a unanimous choice as best player in the league, before the concussion. So , no I don't bring Crosby into a " best of all time arguement " for quite a while. Could turn out to be the best of his generation and a Hall of Famer. If , we hope, he can get past this concussion issue. But that is serious SEE Eric Lindros.
Think Crosby , if healthy, could have an Yzerman type career , someone at that level. Which is damn good , but no where near Gretzky , just easy to forget how dominant Gretzky actually was. He had a vision of the ice like no-one before or since.