Xabi Alonso - would you sell him?

If Barca came sniffing around and offered Eto'o as part of the deal would you take it for a player we desperately need?
I'm not saying i want Xabi to got of course not but sometimes when a once in a lifetime deal comes around you have to take it.

Lets look at Theirry Henry, linked with Barca and of course they were willing to pay big money for him. Instead he stays with Arsenal and has a horror season. Bet all or most Arsenal fans wish they cashed in on him now.

IMO Xabi's best season with us was 04/05 then his 2nd best season was 05/06 so this is possibly his worst season with us, has not impressed me at all and now not even a regular in the Spain national side.

I don't want to compare a great side like us to other teams but thats exactly what I'm going to do.
Chelsea have 4 centre midfielders in Makelele - DM, Essien - CM, Lampard - AM, Ballack - AM. Only 1 really defensive midfielder there.
Man U*d have Carrick - CM, Scholes - AM and i think thats it and they are top of league.
Arsenal have just Gilberto Silva as defensive midfielder.

We have Masch & Xabi as defensive midfielders and Momo is more of a combative midfielder with the energy to run all over the field. Momo is not as defensive as Xabi even though quite a lot of people think he is.

Now i know some responses will be keep them all and get rid of Zenden (correct) but if we keep them all we won't see the real Stevie G and we will see too much tinkering which will mess up the start of the season again!

I think it was Glenbuck who said Xabi was not so mobile, well i think thats true and in this league you need players who have the ability to move around the field quickly and Xabi lacks that. He would suit Barca's style more (slow pace with a lot of passing football)

The real question is.. do we really need Xabi Alonso? Is it time to cash in while the time is perfect?

Personally I would only be happy with Alonso going if firstly we couldn't get David Villa, and secondly he absolutely HAD to be used as a makeweight in a deal for Eto'o. Apart from that, we have never been a selling club and I wouldn't want us to start now.

You make a very good point about us having more defensive CM's than any of the other top teams. This is the way Rafa likes to play, always has been wherever he has managed. I still believe Rafa is keen on going back to a 4-2-3-1 formation more often, but even when he does play 4-4-2 he likes his CM's to be very disciplined defensively. I still see Xabi having a very important role to play at the club, either alongside Mascherano in a 5 man midfield, or playing alongside Sissoko in a 4 man midfield. I have said before that Xabi plays better alongside Momo than anyone else, always being in the right positions to pick up the simple ball once Sissoko's won it.

Definately keep him IMO. He hasn't had a great season, but not many of our players have.

to land Et'o in Anfield ...... Immediatly !!

your right, xabi hasn't had the greatest season ever. but he is there when we need him. today, he saved us many times and helped the plays flow better. he can read the field and knows where to go and when to do what he needs to. he could improve a bit of a lot, but every player has to have some dip in his career. just so long as it doesn't stay that way.

IMO, keep him as long as he's going to improve from now.

Love to keep him. The JM combination looks solid but as you say Ra Ra Rafa if it ment getting in a top striker I'd say yes but Tevez won't cost much so lets keep him!!!! The rest of you like Eto.....not so keen but if it became part of the deal then why not....he's been great for us over the seasons....maybe its time..

Xabi alonso is unsaleable, there is no equal other one, though now this badly

Xabi, just may be unsettled by all this speculation.
Again we played 3 central midfielders, in a system that worked YET AGAIN !!!
 
Why keep posting topics about selling one of our 4 central midfielders 

We have 4 top quality strikers vying for 2 positions, and 4 top quality central midfielders vying for 2 /3 places.
Where is the problem 

If we were taking of signing another CM then I would take things seriously, but come on ...

Xabi, just may be unsettled by all this speculation.
Again we played 3 central midfielders, in a system that worked YET AGAIN !!!
 
Why keep posting topics about selling one of our 4 central midfielders 

That's actually a good question.

I'd only really want Alonso to be sold if he wanted to go. It's been a good while since we've had an engine room that is so diverse and strong. Different options of quality.

I'm not sure how many would agree with me on this, but to bring the title back to LFC, I think the central midfield is well equipped for the job.

Why keep posting topics about selling one of our 4 central midfielders 

We have 4 top quality strikers vying for 2 positions, and 4 top quality central midfielders vying for 2 /3 places.
Where is the problem 

Theres room for all 4 in the squad and all 4 will be needed to mount a serious title challange, the difficult bit may be keeping everyone happy by squad rotation.

Xabi, just may be unsettled by all this speculation.
Again we played 3 central midfielders, in a system that worked YET AGAIN !!!
 
Why keep posting topics about selling one of our 4 central midfielders 

We have 4 top quality strikers vying for 2 positions, and 4 top quality central midfielders vying for 2 /3 places.
Where is the problem 

If we were taking of signing another CM then I would take things seriously, but come on ...

Good point. Stop hyping up about selling one of our central midfielders. It is NOT the problem.

We are not and have never been a selling club. we are the club any true player would want to come to.

We are not and have never been a selling club. we are the club any true player would want to come to.

correction: any TRUE player. we don't want someone like c. ronaldo who makes his own name for a club. this is a team sport and LFC show that in every way. whether its on the pitch, in the office, or on holiday, we set the example for true football around the world.

u misunderstood my posting but your sentiment is correct

never get rid of alonso

I really like Xabi also is a bit out of fit. I like think he will stay in Anfield for a long time but the real question is ... Will Rafa use Xabi to reach is great loved Et'o ?? As you know Barcelona is really interested to sign him.

id keep alonso, we wud lose he great passing!!

After the superb display of yesterday and how well he worked with Mascherano in the middle of the park it would be a mistake. This middlefields has a huge potential, I have my doubt on Xabi this year, he did not performed at his best but yesterday it was a real pleasure to see our players controlling so well the game. Nice one Xabi!

keep alonso, keep gerrard, keep momo, keep mascherano get rid of zenden and this bloody topic!

keep alonso, keep gerrard, keep momo, keep mascherano get rid of zenden and this bloody topic!

Well, Zenden's probably got his last chance now, fighting it out with Gonzales for the LM spot for the rest of the season. I've never really been impressed with him, but his best games do ssem to have come out on the left.

In one word NO

NEVER sell alonso. him, gerrard, masch, and kewell(when he gets better) will be the best midfield in europe. i can see it now...

Check out my answer in Which midfielder would you sell first? in The Kop.
Xabi, Momo, Stevie and Zenden   are in the firing line... which one would you give the bullet?
No prizes for guessing...  :

Check out my answer in Which midfielder would you sell first? in The Kop.
Xabi, Momo, Stevie and Zenden   are in the firing line... which one would you give the bullet?
No prizes for guessing...  :

Well obviously it's going to be Zenden...
I do deserve a prize my friend.

i personally wouldnt sell him but with only 1 year left on his contract and him in no hurry to sign another we may be left with no choice i think with mascherano we have a ready made replacement albeit he is a different type of player than xabi.

No No No absolutely NOT

If were selling Xabi to get Eto'o part of some kind of deal then we need to look into it, otherwise Barca can forget about him.

Well obviously it's going to be Zenden...
I do deserve a prize my friend.

See if you can persuade JD to give you that mug before it wings it's way down under to mattmcg.
He seems a bit miffed... :

Who will score Liverpool's next goal?

Reply to this post with your answer. In the event of a tie...we'll do a draw.  Everyone welcome...let's hope someone from the UK wins or the mug will end up costing me double in delivery!

I'll go for Dirky baby. He is due a goal or three!! Australia as well for me mate!! 

Well nobody got Arbeola, so I guess Dirk was the 'next' goalscorer after that.

Bugger.  Got to send it to Australia.  Have you not got any relatives in the UK that would want it? 

No a deals a deal.  PM me your full address and it will probably be there in about 3 years!

Well done mattmcg.

We have 4 of the best central midfielders in the Prem and possibly the world.

Stevie, Xabi, Momo and Mascherano.

Let's keep it that way. No more selling, no more buying, the central midfield for once is perfect.

If you wanna build a great team you need all those lads. It's a must don't sell anybody.

We have 4 of the best central midfielders in the Prem and possibly the world.

Stevie, Xabi, Momo and Mascherano.

Let's keep it that way. No more selling, no more buying, the central midfield for once is perfect.

someones got a brain we shouldn't even be talking about central midfielders it's up front where we're lacking we have the best midfielders in the prem now we need goals out with fowler and that waste of money bellamy. no more sh*t buys or getting players who are second best more aggers and sissokos and less palettas and pennants

less palettas and pennants

Hold on players take time to settle in right? Agger started off really badly last winter and Momo didn't start off too clever either.

Paletta is a young defender who plays for the reserves (he came straight from Argentina)
Pennant is a new player who needed to adapt to our style, 2nd half of season he's been one of our most impressive players belive it or not.

No, f***in love alonso

As for pennant, think he's getting slightly better, paletta is still young and with agger and carra and now arbeloa (although still haven't seen him play CB yet) I don't think we've got any worries in defence

Can't wait for Aurelio next season, shame he got injured though he was different to all our players

agree...thought Aurelio was looking good....Pennant just isn't up to it...no more chances...nothing against the guy...just isn't good enough...fact

Pennant is deffo good enough for back up, infact watching Pennant this year he's been better than most of our players.. one bad game and he's not good enough for us.. whats this world comming to..

Pennant is deffo good enough for back up, infact watching Pennant this year he's been better than most of our players..

  

 

This year as in 2007 maybe? If you don't belive me watch the highlights since Bolton game on new years day and see who's improved the most

This year as in 2007 maybe? If you don't belive me watch the highlights since Bolton game on new years day and see who's improved the most

You said better than most of our players.

Better than who?  Reina? Finnan? Carragher? Agger? Arbeloa? Riise? Gerrard? Mascherano? Alonso? Crouch?

JD, how come your posts seem to be stuck on 986.....?
don't worry JD just figured it out...when you reply to 1 it doesn't add on

The point isn't 'who has improved the most'. Its not  sports day at school and even the fat kid is going to get an award. The issue is is he good enough to wear the shirt....the answer is a resounding no. He tries, he is enthusiastic but is he the way forward? NO

The point isn't 'who has improved the most'. Its not  sports day at school and even the fat kid is going to get an award. The issue is is he good enough to wear the shirt....the answer is a resounding no. He tries, he is enthusiastic but is he the way forward? NO

now I'm really confused are we talking about the topic - Xabi or are we still on a bout Pennant?

now I'm really confused are we talking about the topic - Xabi or are we still on a bout Pennant?

No, we're talking about sports day at school 

I went to my little sisters sports day last year, I couldn't believe it, it was all throwing bean bags into buckets & walking across a beam without spilling a bucket of water. Last time I checked, neither of these 'sports' were at the olympics. Bring back the 60 yard dash I say. What is the world coming to?

Nice Eddie! Gave me some flash backs to the 'egg and spoon' and the 'sack race'.....actually aren't  those both porn titles?