I think Kuyt was a flop for us when Rafa did persist with him for so long uptop and TBH I wouldn't really know what his natural position is. Doesn't he now play on the right side of midfield for Holland? Personally I wouldn't go back to playing Kuyt upfront because he is too unselfish to play as a striker. Most of his contributions when playing as a striker came outside the 18 yard box, the fella was never in the box to get on the end of something. He was usually running around like a headless chicken elsewhere on the field.
Maybe if he was paired up with someone, but the pressure I think gets to him and he goes into 'industry mode' chasing and harrying down balls all over the pitch. I think when Rafa moved him to the right hand side of our attack, I think it took a lot of pressure off of Dirk to score goals for us and for a good long while the Dutchman did a good job out there I thought.
Granted he took both his goals very well against Spurs and the lad honestly surprised me with that finnish, but during the course of the game when Spurs pinned us back. He o could play in multiple positionwas unable to make the ball stick up top because he isn't the best at controlling the thing and there was no point in trying to slide a ball in behind their defence because the bloke doesn't have the pace to exploit the high line Spurs played.
For me though his lack of movement inside the box and the fact he isn't a clinical, selfish striker leads me to think he's better suited to the wing, where the pressure on finding the onion bag isn't the burden it appeared to be before for him in the strikers role.
Good points you make, but i think we could write a book on the possible causes of Kuyt's problems. The arrival of Torres knocked his confidence, being forced out onto the wing by Benitez, trying to alter your natural instincts, being switched about and various other possibilities. I think it's a combination of multiple variables, a very confusing situation.
What's in the past is in the past and should stay there. I'm just trying to take the positives out of Kuyt's performance, and let's be honest here, there haven't been many to take this season. Hopefully Kuyt can kick on from this performance against Spurs and score a couple more against Wolves on Tuesday night. Redkenny made a point that Kuyt should have scored a couple more against Spurs, and he was right, but given Kuyt's mental state, i can forgive him for that. The fact that we took the three points made the misses easier to stomach.
Also i'd like to reply to a post made by flafson, yes mate, it would be great to have numerous players who could play in various positions, but there's an old saying mate, 'Jack of all trades, master of none'. I'm a plumber by trade, so it's like someone hiring me and asking me to rewire their house. I could count on one hand the number of players in Europe who could play in multiple positions, and more importantly, play very well in all positions. Players like Gerrard, Messi, Kaka and Ronaldo. Players like these cost an absolute fortune, and money is something we don't have.
I never expected Kuyt to cut it as a winger, despite his exceptional season of last, because he is a striker. To expect him to be of equal ability on the wing is just wishful thinking.
Logged