Alan Smith (The Mancs)

Yes, before I post my opinion, thank god I live in the US, because you guys would be hunting me down. Alan Smith is still not signed or given a new contract by Man U. I like him, he plays with fire. He is aggresive and has a pretty good finishing touch. Had a horrible injury, but recovered well. Didn't get that much playing time with Man U, but I watched him play in the Roma game and he looked good. I'm not saying he is our first, second, or third choice for a striker, but he has played in the Premiership, and is use to the wear and tear in what I like to call " The Mens leauge" which is top flight English soccer. In my opinion the toughest league in the world. I would sign him. Thats if all else fails.

hmmm

I wouldnt sign him, and if we did I would be very worried about where we were going.............

agree with you in that he plays with aggresion and heart but would be disappointed if we signed him as i cant see him scoring 20 goals a season.not a bad player tho

Yes, before I post my opinion, thank god I live in the US, because you guys would be hunting me down. Alan Smith is still not signed or given a new contract by Man U. I like him, he plays with fire. He is aggresive and has a pretty good finishing touch. Had a horrible injury, but recovered well. Didn't get that much playing time with Man U, but I watched him play in the Roma game and he looked good. I'm not saying he is our first, second, or third choice for a striker, but he has played in the Premiership, and is use to the wear and tear in what I like to call " The Mens leauge" which is top flight English soccer. In my opinion the toughest league in the world. I would sign him. Thats if all else fails.

Alan Smith wouldn't even be in my top ten choices for a strikers to join the club. I don't think he offers anything that we don't already have and in my opinion isn't as good as any of our current forwards so would be a step backwards. Strange topic!!

And didn't he turn us down to join Man Uer?? Fcuk him

Jack of all trades, master of none. He can play a lot of positions, but isn't world class in any of them. We need to bring in class this summer, we have enough 'utility' players in the squad.

alan smith is just not even in the game any more im soory but alan smith is just a big no no

we should take this post of the forum ,

it is just silly to even think hes any good, any way come on eveyone he is a very average player..

iam i not right or iam i right..

Yes, before I post my opinion, thank god I live in the US, because you guys would be hunting me down.

Lester - hunt him down!

Wouldn't have him.  He's not an out and out striker and he wouldn't touch any of our midfield players. Sorry Glenn I reckon you've got this one wrong.

iam I not right or iam I right..

dont see what the point is of buying alan smith because dirk peter craig are all better in my opinion

Smith hasn't done enough in his time at Man Ure to move sideways, i.e. to a team like us, Chelsea or Arsenal.

I'd expect a Villa, Newcastle, Everton etc...to be his next port of a call

dirk peter craig

He sounds the dogs swingers. How much? If he costs more than £5 million tho  we can't have him

if alan smith wasn't playin for the mancs then i would say lets  sign him!!

not good enough for utd not worth pissing on then.

He sounds the dogs swingers. How much? If he costs more than £5 million tho  we can't have him

Imagine havinga player with the pace of Bellamy, the height of Crouch, and the Work rate of Dirk!!

Still wouldn't be the world class finisher we need!

Hmm, how about the height of Crouch, the pace of Bellamy, work rate of Kuyt and the finishing of a young Fowler?

Christ, that could be the best striker in the world.

if alan smith wasn't playin for the mancs then I would say lets  sign him!!

Seconded

if alan smith wasn't playin for the mancs then I would say lets  sign him!!

Disagree. It's got nothing to do with him playing for Man Utd for me. He just is not the quality of player we sholud be looking for this summer.