Benitez and his final days at Liverpool
Former chairman says Rafa was never sacked but felt he had to walk away from Anfield
BROUGHTON ON RAFA
The background...
Sir Martin Broughton was the man who sold Liverpool. The man who went through the courts to prise the club out of the much-despised hands of George Gillett and Tom Hicks.
It was he who Hicks infamously accused of being the orchestrator of âan epic swindleâ over the sale of the club.
His six months as chairman of Liverpool FC were some of the most dramatic in the clubâs 125 year history. Seven years this week after his appointment in April 2010 - and finally clear of years of legal wrangling - he spoke with Neil Jones and Andy Kelly about those astonishing times at Anfield.
He revealed for the first time the inner workings of a club which at the time was in the midst of a civil war.
The man who sold Liverpool - 90 minutes with Sir Martin Broughton
But here, Sir Martin Broughton gives his version of the final days of Rafa Benitez.
The popular Spaniard left Anfield less than two months after the new chairmanâs arrival - and has a very different view of those final weeks - but Broughton now insists he never wanted him to go.
'I didn't sack Rafa'
The circumstances surrounding Rafa Benitezâs exit as Liverpool manager have been discussed in depth for the first time - by the man who let him go.
Sir Martin Broughton was Liverpoolâs chairman at the time of Benitezâs departure in 2010, having been appointed by RBS bank to find new owners that could take over from the despised pair of Tom Hicks and George Gillett.
Hicks and Gillett owed the bank in the region of ÂŁ300m and RBS wanted a sale of the club to ensure that loan was repaid.
It was agreed that Sir Martin would take a seat on the LFC board to progress a sale within six months and he was given the casting vote among that five strong board.
But within days of his arrival on Merseyside, the former British Airways chairman found himself at the centre of a storm involving Benitez and Christian Purslow, then the Redsâ managing director.
And in an exclusive, 90-minute interview with the ECHO for Anfield Extra subscribers, Broughton has lifted the lid on those days and weeks, insisting: âI never wanted Rafa to go.â
Sir Martin said: âThe one thing I did not want to do was to sack Rafa. And the reason for that was nothing to do with my relationship with Rafa. The reason was that I felt the right people to decide who the new manager should be, or that it should be Rafa, were the new owners.
âThe wrong person to decide that was me, who had been brought in to find a new owner on a temporary basis. So I was very clear in my position that Rafa stays.
âAs you are aware at that time, there was a very unhealthy atmosphere at that time, where there were three cliques basically. You had the owners, you had the manager and you had the executive, all leaking to people against the other two â and there was a sub-division of that between the two owners as well.
âRafa had his own full-time PR person who was managing his position.
âI had expected, given that, that with me coming on board, Rafa would actually make an effort to align himself with a potential ally. It turned out to be quite different.
âThis may be me being old fashioned, but I didnât want my first meeting with Rafa to be on the phone. I wanted a face-to-face meeting.
âAlmost immediately after I was appointed, there was a match on a Monday night (against West Ham) so I sent a message to Rafa that I would like to have breakfast with him on the Tuesday morning. Donât interfere with the manager on the day of the match, so letâs have breakfast the next morning.
âThat was fine, but it turned out that that was the week with the volcanic ash problems, and Liverpool were off to Spain on the Thursday.
âThey were leaving Tuesday lunchtime, so I didnât think that would stop Rafa from meeting Tuesday morning. That wouldnât have been an issue for me, but in the early hours of the morning a message went from Rafa to Christian Purslow to say that he couldnât meet me because he had to be off Tuesday lunchtime.
âI didnât really understand that. I had been at the club three days maybe at this point, and still hadnât met him. So anyway he went off to Spain, then the following weekend there was an away game (at Burnley) which I didnât go to.
âThen the following week there was the replay (second leg, against Atletico Madrid) and again I asked to meet for breakfast the day after the match.
âLiverpool won the game but went out on away goals, and again in the early hours comes a message that says âIâm too distraught with the result, my headâs not in the right place, I canât meetâ.
âTo me, this is getting weird. This was the second opportunity to meet, just for a chat.
âBut on the Saturday, in his pre-match chat with the TV, Rafa says âI donât understand what is going on here, the new chairman has been here nearly two weeks and Iâve not even met him yet!â
âI thought âhmm, I see the tone of things now!â But I still didnât want him to go. Iâm used to people playing silly games at times, so I thought letâs keep it straight.â
Broughton did eventually meet Benitez, and detailed the discussions which took place at that face-to-face.
He said: âWe had an interesting thing where I did then meet him, and I had a two-hour download from Rafa, without being able to get a word in, where he told me what was wrong.
âThat was fine, get it off your chest, itâs not a complaint at all. I like to hear his version. I then had another meeting with him maybe a week later, and got the same two-hour download.
âI kept interrupting âRafa, you told me that...â and he said âyou just need to hear this...â before we could have a conversation.
âEssentially, I was saying to him âwhat do you need?â In my background, if you want investment you say what is wrong, what have you tried to do about it that hasnât worked, what do you need and how is it going to work.
âHe had come with a shopping list which included, for example, a left back. And I said âRafa, youâve been here six years, and youâve bought six left backs and youâre telling me none of them have worked. So what are you going to differently this time?â There was no answer.
âI asked him to write down everything he wanted and why it was going to work. And he did. He thought it was totally incomprehensible from a football viewpoint but he did it!
âAnd I was beginning to think we were starting to get on the right wavelength, when it became obvious that he wanted to have discussions through his lawyer â and thatâs when it became obvious that he wanted out.â
Benitez would eventually see out the 2009/10 season, but left Liverpool âby mutual consentâ on June 3, 2010, stating that he was âextremely sadâ to be going. He was appointed by then European Champions Inter Milan a week later.
âI think heâd probably already decided heâd had enough before I got there,â Broughton said. âThe atmosphere was pretty awful, and I think heâd seen the opportunity to maybe get out with a new person coming in.
âI didnât want to get distracted by all of this. And it was very interesting that the fan input to me personally, a bit face to face but usually via e-mail, was about 50-50 â there was no moderate â it was totally polarised.
âIt was âdo not get rid of Rafaâ to âthis club will never go forward unless Rafa goesâ. It was about 50-50, but they were total polar opposites. My idea was still that he would stay.
âRafa basically pulled out of the whole thing and said âIâm going to leave this to my lawyers to negotiate.â
âHe didnât say he was leaving, and I never told him he was leaving. It was âIâll leave this to my lawyerâ and his lawyerâs stance was âwhat are the terms for Rafa goingâ?â
Was there any thought that Rafa going could make the sale of the club easier?
âI donât think I saw it as making the process easier. I found having to deal with the exit of the manager a distraction, and getting in the way of what I was trying to do. I would have preferred he stayed.
âDid it have the impact of having one less problem to deal with? Yes. But had he stayed and not been a problem, that would have been better still!â
Broughton, of course, replaced Benitez with Roy Hodgson, who proved to be one of the worst managerial appointments in Liverpool history
Echo
