We need at least one first team left back. The likes of Mavinga and Robinson are decent plan B options, I don't think they're a realistic Plan A though. Look at a player like Insua, was brilliant when he was used sparingly and was actually competing against a first teamer for a spot but confidence looked shot to pieces by the end of the campaign when he was our default #1 choice and seemed to almost take it for granted.
I think Roy needs to be not scared of playing the likes of Carragher, Agger or Johnson at left back should the situation arise and the youngsters [Mavinga/Robinson/Darby/Kelly/Degen - yes I know he's not a youngster but still you get the point] don't look up to the challenge. We've got a decent amount of defenders and a fair amount of them are versatile enough, some competition for spots wouldn't go astray.
Logged