"Judge me after 10 games" (Roy Hodgson)

League: D
Europa League: B+
League Cup: F
Transfers: C-
Media: F
Youth Development: D
Tactics: D-
Man-management: D-

Overall: D

This is a post by vitez slightly edited but i agree 100% and it proves he has failed what are your opinions on the above ?

Only just got to D- after the Bolton win. Wouldve been an F before. Transfers D. Two poor buys and meireles who looks good. Also let out aqua..

League: D
Europa League: B+
League Cup: F
Transfers: C-
Media: F
Youth Development: D
Tactics: D-
Man-management: D-

Overall: D

This is a post by vitez slightly edited but I agree 100% and it proves he has failed what are your opinions on the above ?

Can't argue with this assessment, on a positive note, the last two perfomrances have been markably better in terms of shape, penetration, pressing and chance creation. Great result against a tough Bolton side, lets keep the momentum going in the right direction. I am prepared to give Roy a chance, but unlike a lot of other managers in the past, I like a lot of other people will need some convincing .. wether thats fair or not is another matter but still it is what it is ... over to you Roy ...

Hes a clever guy and sure he is on the up and up on what the perception is

League - F (Liverpool should never be in the relegation zone after 9 games, that is a failure to me)
Europa - B (Doing okay there, but not mind-blowing bar that one good win)
League Cup - F (No excuse there)
Transfers - C- Raul good, Poulsen & Konchesky not so good)
Media - F (Never have i seen so much sh*t come out of a managers mouth in such a short stint)
Youth - D (He's making Rafa's so called bad youth management look brilliant, i mean where the F**k has Dani been?!)
Tactics - F (Utter sh*t again, for the most part)
Man Management - D (Again, utter sh*t it seems but don't know the full story yet)

OVERALL - F+ (Just bumps to a plus with the couple wins, but still is F***ing absolute sh*t as i see it)

he said he would play pacheo give him playing time. why is not even a sub promising young player rejected. just dont get it   

Judgement : Fired

Judgement : Fired

Just because I'm a boss, I'm going to copy paste exactly what I wrote in the "Is Roy the Right Man thread":

I'd love to know what other people think of Hodgson on a more linear scale.  The whole concept of yes/no/undecided seems a little 'divide and conqueresque' (I know that's that's not a word, but it should be).  So come on fellow forum members, rate Hodgson on a few key areas that you feel are important (feel free to use some or all of mine; add or subtract as necessary - all depends on what's important to you) and let's try and get a little bit more of an in depth view on Hodgson.  School teacher marks, ratings out of 10, star ratings, anything that's a little more scale based

A few more criteria to judge him on (if you choose):

Planning for the future
You might want to split up tactics into home/away; defending/attacking; passing/tackling.

You might want to add what you feel is an acceptable mark for now or what is acceptable in the future.  Anything really.

edit: Instead of posts like "Judgment:Fired" could you perhaps elaborate and say well he's got an F in this criteria and I believe that a bare minimum of C is required.  If you find it easier, just judge him out of 10 in say 10 categories and maintain that 60 (random number) is acceptable but only if it improves to a 75 by Christmas or something like that.

if we beat chelsea somehow i will give him an overall A+

if we beat chelsea somehow I will give him an overall A+

Even if it's by an own goal by Terry in the last minute?

I just think dani pacheco should play and that would give roy a C- not a D-

Well I for one, would not be trying to bed a promising talented youth player during this tirade of utter .... right now, better to give him a run out when the team is flying high on confidence ... he would get slaughtered if he let him run out and we got beat badly

League - F (Liverpool should never be in the relegation zone after 9 games, that is a failure to me)
Europa - B (Doing okay there, but not mind-blowing bar that one good win)
League Cup - F (No excuse there)
Transfers - C- Raul good, Poulsen & Konchesky not so good)
Media - F (Never have I seen so much sh*t come out of a managers mouth in such a short stint)
Youth - D (He's making Rafa's so called bad youth management look brilliant, I mean where the f**k has Dani been?!)
Tactics - F (Utter sh*t again, for the most part)
Man Management - D (Again, utter sh*t it seems but don't know the full story yet)

OVERALL - F+ (Just bumps to a plus with the couple wins, but still is f**king absolute sh*t as I see it)

That is an honest assessment so I will just say ditto and it will save me repeating your post.

League - F (Liverpool should never be in the relegation zone after 9 games, that is a failure to me)
Europa - B (Doing okay there, but not mind-blowing bar that one good win)
League Cup - F (No excuse there)
Transfers - C- Raul good, Poulsen & Konchesky not so good)
Media - F (Never have I seen so much sh*t come out of a managers mouth in such a short stint)
Youth - D (He's making Rafa's so called bad youth management look brilliant, I mean where the f**k has Dani been?!)
Tactics - F (Utter sh*t again, for the most part)
Man Management - D (Again, utter sh*t it seems but don't know the full story yet)

OVERALL - F+ (Just bumps to a plus with the couple wins, but still is f**king absolute sh*t as I see it)

can't argue with theat assesment really

Can't argue with this assessment, on a positive note, the last two perfomrances have been markably better in terms of shape, penetration, pressing and chance creation. Great result against a tough Bolton side, lets keep the momentum going in the right direction. I am prepared to give Roy a chance, but unlike a lot of other managers in the past, I like a lot of other people will need some convincing .. wether thats fair or not is another matter but still it is what it is ... over to you Roy ...

Hes a clever guy and sure he is on the up and up on what the perception is

Why does that make me think of sex?

Why does that make me think of sex?

Because your a horny young adoloescent male ?

Why does that make me think of sex?

Because your a horny young adoloescent male ?

Are you two twins ?

Why does that make me think of sex?

Penetration, Penetration,........Penetration?

penetration

if we beat chelsea somehow I will give him an overall A+

I'd go with B+ with a smiley face, roys not outa the Woods yet.

Overall the results have been poor, the quality of our football has been poor and individually players have been poor.His man management has been poor , his purchases have been poor and his media and PR has been awful.
Overall a f***in disaster.

judgement: failed. out out.

Verdict: Off you pop Mr Hodgson,we wish you every success in your future employment.
We would wish him that but his own expectations would be considerably lower.