I just made vanilla and pear flavoured porridge for breakfast which makes me equally as qualified to be a good judge of character of who will make the grade at Liverpool. If you're confused, the point I'm making is that how long you've been watching Liverpool doesn't qualify you any better to make a decision about who will make the grade here or not. If you truthfully believe it does, then I would have been spot on in my assessment of you.
You state the reasoning that he's a product of the previous regime and then dismiss my claims that so were Agger, Kuyt and Reina too as rubbish. You're spot on, it is rubbish. I only used that example so it would be clear to you how stupid saying something like that was.
You then ask what's that got to do with your opinion on Maxi, nothing - but proceed to mention that you've been watching Liverpool since the 1980s again and act as if that's some defining factor in deciding what constitutes a Liverpool player. Liverpool have had many unspectacular players over the years, it's not about who has the most "best players" it's about who has the best team.
If he's had a "good spell" under Kenny, why is it so out of the realms of possibility that he could keep it going. As for my alleged football knowledge, you should be questioning it, because if it or the logic that I have used to reach my conclusions is wrong - it should be up for scrutiny.
Saying Maxi is not versatile is wrong. He can play comfortably in a number of positions.
Saying Maxi is very dire is wrong. The fact you believe he's "very dire" instead of "not quite good enough" leads me to believe you're on a genuine crusade against him.
Saying Maxi has no "definitive attributes" again is probably helping my argument more about this is genuinely about "how you see football" rather that it being a case of "Maxi having no definite attributes".
Quality little snide remark at the end though, but I'm pleased you wouldn't stoop to such "childish depths" and "sarcastic managerial comments" because you're above all that. I may be am a c**t but I don't pretend I'm above it. I'm off for a jog now.
I just made vanilla and pear flavoured porridge for breakfast which makes me equally as qualified to be a good judge of character of who will make the grade at Liverpool. If you're confused, the point I'm making is that how long you've been watching Liverpool doesn't qualify you any better to make a decision about who will make the grade here or not. If you truthfully believe it does, then I would have been spot on in my assessment of you.What the f**k are you babbling on about?. I'm just saying that I have been following Liverpool for nearly 30 years and during that time I have seen a lot of great players here who were worthy of wearing the shirt and a lot who haven't been worthy. Nowhere in that post did I say that this made my opinion any more valid than yours. Maxi has not got the Liverpool style about him, again, this is my opinion.
You state the reasoning that he's a product of the previous regime and then dismiss my claims that so were Agger, Kuyt and Reina too as rubbish. You're spot on, it is rubbish. I only used that example so it would be clear to you how stupid saying something like that was. What the f**k are you on about again?. What the f**k have Agger, Kuyt and Reina got to do with a post that is about Maxi?, the answer is absolutely nothing. I said that Maxi was the product of a previous regime, a bad product. If I thought the aforementioned players were bad I would have stated that, though clearly I didn't.
You then ask what's that got to do with your opinion on Maxi, nothing - but proceed to mention that you've been watching Liverpool since the 1980s again and act as if that's some defining factor in deciding what constitutes a Liverpool player. Liverpool have had many unspectacular players over the years, it's not about who has the most "best players" it's about who has the best team.I clearly stated that the fact that Agger, Reina and Kuyt were products of the previous regime had f**k all to do with my assessment of Maxi. It has no f**king relevance whatsoever. So what is your f**king point?.
If he's had a "good spell" under Kenny, why is it so out of the realms of possibility that he could keep it going. As for my alleged football knowledge, you should be questioning it, because if it or the logic that I have used to reach my conclusions is wrong - it should be up for scrutiny.I never said it was out of the realms of possibility that Maxi could keep it going. I just don't rate the lad. He's a freeloader who is milking this Club for all he can get. Another one of Rafa's failings in my opinion. I don't want players here who are perceived to be decent squad players as in my eyes they are not worthy of the shirt.
Saying Maxi is not versatile is wrong. He can play comfortably in a number of positions.
Saying Maxi is very dire is wrong. The fact you believe he's "very dire" instead of "not quite good enough" leads me to believe you're on a genuine crusade against him.
Saying Maxi has no "definitive attributes" again is probably helping my argument more about this is genuinely about "how you see football" rather that it being a case of "Maxi having no definite attributes".Why is saying Maxi is not versatile wrong?. Why is saying Maxi has been very dire wrong?. Are people not allowed opinions?. Is this not a forum?. If a poll was to be put up asking if Maxi is worthy of a regular first eleven starting place then I think that it would make very interesting reading.
I think the fact that most people see him a good squad player speaks for itself in all honesty, don't you?.
Quality little snide remark at the end though, but I'm pleased you wouldn't stoop to such "childish depths" and "sarcastic managerial comments" because you're above all that. I may be am a c**t but I don't pretend I'm above it. I'm off for a jog now.It wasn't a snide remark, yet you chose to see it as that. In my country it is a term used to say,"End of."
The reason I choose not to question your knowledge is that I don't really care in all honesty. You have an opinion and I have an opinion, it's not about who is right to me, it's about what way it affects Liverpool.
Logged