Trending Topics

      Next match: v [] Thu 1st Jan @ 1:00 am

      Today is the 5th of June and on this date LFC's match record is P3 W2 D1 L0

      David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead

      Read 10957 times
      0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
      Billy1
      • Forum Legend - Paisley
      • *****

      • 10,638 posts | 1966 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #23: Aug 05, 2013 10:04:51 am
      I suggest we send our 2 owners a copy of this each. After reading it, they should then ask themselves if they are the right people to return this club to its former glories.
      Bill would be horrified to see how the game he loved is now more about money and ego, than football.
      He would be horrified at the actions and attitude of many modern day footballers. Maybe football needs to reacquaint itself with the Shankly way, if it doesn't it is going to gorge itself from the inside out!
      Now he truly was a Legend.
      I totally agree with all you say but I doubt our owners would ever begin to understand what Bill Shankly,Anfield and L.F.C. means to our fans.
      Redangel
      • Forum Legend - Dalglish
      • *****

      • 8,391 posts | 1025 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #24: Aug 05, 2013 10:31:24 am
      I totally agree with all you say but I doubt our owners would ever begin to understand what Bill Shankly,Anfield and L.F.C. means to our fans.

      You're probably right, but reading this book may just give them a little insight into the psyche of this club.
      Then again you can only open your mind to things if you are interested, I think many of us are now questioning just how interested they are in the footballing side of this Football Club.
      reddebs
      • "LFC Hipster"
      • Forum Legend - Paisley
      • *****

      • 17,980 posts | 2264 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #25: Aug 05, 2013 10:39:53 am
      You're probably right, but reading this book may just give them a little insight into the psyche of this club.
      Then again you can only open your mind to things if you are interested, I think many of us are now questioning just how interested they are in the footballing side of this Football Club.

      Why would Capitalist Americans be interested in the Socialist views of Bill Shankly hun, Bill's ideology is completely alien to them. 

      Redangel
      • Forum Legend - Dalglish
      • *****

      • 8,391 posts | 1025 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #26: Aug 05, 2013 11:05:42 am
      Why would Capitalist Americans be interested in the Socialist views of Bill Shankly hun, Bill's ideology is completely alien to them. 



      You're right of course Debs, but at least trying to understand where this club has its roots, could help them understand why we view with such horror some of the things they have done.
      As I said though, that would need them to actually care and be interested, it's obvious they neither care nor are they interested.
      Shanks would have seen through them and the last two straight away.
      reddebs
      • "LFC Hipster"
      • Forum Legend - Paisley
      • *****

      • 17,980 posts | 2264 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #27: Aug 05, 2013 11:21:14 am
      You're right of course Debs, but at least trying to understand where this club has its roots, could help them understand why we view with such horror some of the things they have done.
      As I said though, that would need them to actually care and be interested, it's obvious they neither care nor are they interested.
      Shanks would have seen through them and the last two straight away.


      I don't necessarily think it's about not caring or being uninterested hun, they seem to just think that because they "saved" us we should be grateful for everything they do, whether it goes against our beliefs, principals, morals and spirit or not.

      They don't "get" why we think some of the their behaviour is abhorrent to us, why their lack of respect grates so much, why we question their decisions.

      To me they are the archetypal lords of the manor and we are just another piece of real estate to add to their portfolio.

      Bill Shankly and his philosophy's are as far removed from theirs than you could possibly get.
      waltonl4
      • LFC Reds Subscriber
      • ******
      • 37,730 posts | 7164 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #28: Aug 05, 2013 01:16:22 pm
      to me LFC still represents what is good about the working class man (or should do).It was also Shankly's belief in working hard together but sharing the rewards this is not FSG's mantra.
      reddebs
      • "LFC Hipster"
      • Forum Legend - Paisley
      • *****

      • 17,980 posts | 2264 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #29: Aug 05, 2013 01:32:09 pm
      to me LFC still represents what is good about the working class man (or should do).It was also Shankly's belief in working hard together but sharing the rewards this is not FSG's mantra.

      Exactly mate.
      srslfc
      • Forum Legend - Shankly
      • ******

      • 32,348 posts | 4968 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #30: Aug 06, 2013 09:55:19 am
      Just started reading this and already really enjoying it.

      Someone remarked above about Peace's writing style and it's true he has a certain way of writing but it kind of drwas you in.
      JD
      • LFC Reds Subscriber
      • ******
      • 39,685 posts | 6981 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #31: Aug 06, 2013 04:22:30 pm
      Just started reading this. I'm really liking it.  The reading. Of the book that is. Liking it. A lot.
      Diego LFC
      • Forum Legend - Paisley
      • *****

      • 19,335 posts | 2836 
      • Sempre Liverpool
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #32: Aug 06, 2013 04:37:43 pm
      Just started reading this. I'm really liking it.  The reading. Of the book that is. Liking it. A lot.

      Sounds interesting. Hope to get it soon. The book that is. Not your post. Know if it's available for Kindle?
      italianred83
      • On Trial

      • 1 posts |
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #33: Aug 06, 2013 05:10:45 pm
      If you're interested, I've just published an interview with David Peace on the Channel 4 News website: http://www.channel4.com/news/david-peace-bill-shankly-red-or-dead-red-riding-video

      Am a big fan of Peace and Shankly. Look forward to reading it  ;)
      Son Of A Gun
      • Forum Legend - Dalglish
      • *****

      • 5,199 posts | 1275 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #34: Aug 06, 2013 09:38:19 pm
      The Damned United and 44 Years With The Same Bird are my favourite football books. Hopefully Peace can continue the form he had with The Damned United.

      P.S. Just a wee thought, but does anyone else think that Fever Pitch is the most overrated football book ever? I found the book bang average - I don't know whether it just appealed to upper class part time football fans.
      srslfc
      • Forum Legend - Shankly
      • ******

      • 32,348 posts | 4968 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #35: Aug 06, 2013 10:23:30 pm
      Just started reading this. I'm really liking it.  The reading. Of the book that is. Liking it. A lot.

      Nice. :D





      HUYTON RED
      • Forum Legend - Shankly
      • ******
      • Started Topic

      • 40,493 posts | 8676 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #36: Aug 06, 2013 10:27:59 pm
      P.S. Just a wee thought, but does anyone else think that Fever Pitch is the most overrated football book ever? I found the book bang average - I don't know whether it just appealed to upper class part time football fans.

      Plus the ending is sh*te!

      wolves76
      • Forum Paul Ince
      • *

      • 84 posts |
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #37: Aug 07, 2013 10:36:47 pm
      The thing about Fever Pitch is that it was overrated because before its publication most books relating to football were pretty sh*t.  I remember reading Steve Kellys review of the book in the brilliant fanzine TTWAR. He took on Nick Hornby in a sarcastic and biting manner that Steve was so renowned for.  I thought it was ok myself but not as good as the chattering classes gave credit to it.

      I cant wait to read Red or Dead.  Peace is my favourite contemporary author so I was thrilled when I found out he was writing a book on Shankly. I love all his books and as one person has already mentioned, the style of the prose is almost hypnotic. It draws you in to such an extend that you become hooked. I am sure this book will ensure an expanding audience for this superb writer.
      HUYTON RED
      • Forum Legend - Shankly
      • ******
      • Started Topic

      • 40,493 posts | 8676 
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #38: Aug 09, 2013 11:31:43 am
      I remember reading Steve Kellys review of the book in the brilliant fanzine TTWAR.

      Now we're talking, that fanzine was superb, used to love reading the diary during half-time!
      RedPuppy
      • Still European.
      • LFC Reds Subscriber
      • ******
      • 19,264 posts | 2859 
      • Parum Rutilus Canis: Illegitimi non carborundum
      Re: David Peace's New Book About Bill Shankly - Red Or Dead
      Reply #39: Aug 10, 2013 04:49:44 pm
      Red or Dead
      David Peace's Red or Dead is Radio 4ā€™s Book at Bedtime. You can listen to episode 1 of Red or Dead from Monday 12 August



      Why did you choose Bill Shankly?

      I think it was not so much that I chose Bill Shankly as - and it might sound a bit over romantic or even arrogant to some people ā€“ Bill Shankly chose me really. I was a bit tired of contributing to narratives of despair and defeat and I wanted to write a book about a good man for a change. I was struggling to think what kind of book to do and how to write that narrative when a film producer asked would I like to write a film script about the life of Bill Shankly. And before heā€™d even finished the sentence, I was like, absolutely. But first I need to write a novel.

      It was as though Bill Shankly had been sat in the room all along - Iā€™d not noticed him. Growing up, I was a Huddersfield Town supporter and Bill Shankly ā€“ well before my time ā€“ was a manager at Huddersfield Town. My father and grandfather often talked about him. He features in The Damned United as well. In the original first edition, if you take off the cover, heā€™s there. It felt like something Iā€™d been waiting to write. People might say its hyperbole but youā€™d be hard pushed to find a better man to write about than Bill Shankly.

      What do you think it is about Bill Shankly that makes him such an enduring cultural icon?

      This was a man who changed and transformed peopleā€™s lives, whether they were the players or the supporters. He had endless time for ordinary people. You could knock on his door and he would invite you in for a cup of tea. He personally answered all the letters he received. So people have this whole reservoir of stories and memories ā€“ folk memories from people on Merseyside - of what this man meant to them and how he changed their lives.

      Everybody he met, he always thought the best of them, and brought the best out of them. And he always, always treated people equally. And it comes back to the fact that he was a socialist ā€“ not in the way that he read a great lot of political literature or theory, but in the way he treated everybody equally, the way that he believed everybody deserved equality of opportunity, that it wasnā€™t about the individual - that it was about the team, the community, and that everybody worked for each other on the pitch as the team and off the pitch as the club. He represents socialism in its most beautiful and simplest form.

      Every day of his life, every hour of his life ā€“ he lived it with these principles. Shankly said that he was ā€œmade for Liverpool.ā€ Could Shankly have achieved greatness anywhere, or was Liverpool essential to making him the man, and the  manager, that he became?

      As a Huddersfield Town supporter, and being that Huddersfield was the club he left for Liverpool, we Huddersfield Town supporters always think: had our board given him the money to buy Ian St John, then Huddersfield Town would have the same legacy and status that Liverpool Football Club still have to this day. But at the risk of alienating and annoying every Huddersfield Town supporter out there, I think in all honesty that Shankly went to Liverpool because he knew that even though Liverpool were in the second division, there was a fervour to the supporters that he felt he could help awaken and thatā€™s what he did. He instinctively knew that this was the city for him.

      Do you have a soundtrack to get yourself into the atmosphere of a time period and if so, what was it for Red or Dead?

      When Iā€™m writing, I always try to use the music of the time Iā€™m writing about. Going back to my first book, 1974, I listened to Diamond Dogs by David Bowie over and over again. I think the music of a particular time can help you recapture the language - because language changes all the time. With Red or Dead ā€“ it was a little bit more difficult. Bill Shankly himself liked what I might describe as easy listening ā€“ Jim Reeves, Pat Boone, Mario Lanza ā€“ and I did dutifully go and buy a lot of the music he listened to. To be honest ā€“ shall we say ā€“ I found it a little bit distracting to listen to it. Iā€™m a huge admirer of Shostakovich and his historical symphonies based on certain years.  That music captured something about the crowd scenes and the football scenes. And Shostakovich himself was a huge football fan ā€“ he supported St Petersburg.

      You mentioned that you were in a band when you were a teenager ā€“ what was it called?

      The Paunchy Cowboys. We recorded a lot of demos in studios in Leeds ā€“ we have the demo tapes  -but so far thereā€™s not been the demand to see them digitalisedā€¦

      With Sir Alex Ferguson retiring and Red or Dead covering Bill Shanklyā€™s retirement, can we draw comparisons between the pair?

      Sir Alex Ferguson was a great admirer of Bill Shankly and there are stories that when Sir Alex Ferguson was at Aberdeen, he used to play tapes of Bill Shankly speaking on the Aberdeen bus ā€“ much to the horror of some of the players. I think there is a good comparison between what Sir Alex Ferguson achieved when he was manager of Aberdeen, and what Bill Shankly did when he came to Liverpool. By the time Sir Alex Ferguson goes to Manchester United, youā€™d need to compare him with Bob Paisley. Manchester United had not been as successful in previous years, but when Bill Shankly went to Liverpool they were in the second division. Manchester United were not in the second division. So itā€™s more useful to compare Fergusonā€™s Manchester United period with Paisley at Liverpool.

      Itā€™s been said that after your 12th book, youā€™ve threatened to stop writing altogether ā€“ is that true?

      The daft things you say in interviews! Iā€™d written Occupied City, which was my eighth book, and I think Iā€™d written myself into a bit of a corner. As I say, I was looking for a different kind of narrative; a different story. And at that time before Bill Shankly came calling, I did find the thought of four more dark books a bit too much. But the bad news is, Iā€™ve changed my mind. I think thereā€™ll be more books. Sorry.

      Listen to Red or Dead

      http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/radio4/posts/Red-or-Dead

      If you click on the page link, there are a few more sound bites.

      Quick Reply