Swab, do you not think it is possible that our inability to keep hold of the ball up top is one of the reasons? It's not just Gerrard that has to defend, there are 2 other midfielders out there and when our full backs are not quick enough to recover from possession loss at the top end of the pitch our shape is twisted. A lot of blame has to be apportioned to the defence also, when a full back attacks then the defence has to adjust formation to compensate. We are not seeing that this Season.
I think there are multiple reasons.
The FB's are far too quick to get forwards, and not nearly quick enough to get back.
When the CB's split, it leaves Gerrard far too isolated in the centre and his recovery is not there. Whether he can get it back remains to be seen.
Too many players are making bad decisions, including Gerrard about when to pass it safe, or when to take a risk.
We are predictable in all area's of the pitch.
We seem to overthink things, and players are trying to be too clever at times which just means we give the ball away.
Our crossing is piss poor.
Our interplay in tight areas is just not there.
Shooting chances open up, but players elect to try and thread it through a packed area.
Our line is either too high or too deep, and we rarely get it right.
Set piece defending is a nightmare.
Last season we saw the defense drift and one fullback at a time going forwards (mostly), which always left 4 men at the back and even then we had problems.
Gerrard is playing at the bottom point of an inverted midfield triangle, if that makes sense.
For me, it is his job to screen in front of the back four, and he's not doing that very well, and to be honest, he never has.
He is a hugely talented footballer, but defending has never been his strongest point.
I said in the BR thread that the manager, his staff and the players need to get back to basics.
The best managers I have seen in 50 years watching the game have always built their teams from the back.
BR doesn't seem to want to do that, and sometimes, I get the feeling that he is trying to be too clever for his own good.