Don’t think my heart could take it if it goes to penalties. Milner is the best kicker so he should take the first for me. I though of VVD but read on Transfermarkt that he hasn’t taken a penalty in his entire career, same for Roberson and Lovren.
Milner (22 scored 5 missed)
Trent (4 scored 0 missed)
Gini (7 scored 4 missed)
Bobby (4 scored 4 missed)
Mo (5 scored 1 missed)
The other takers I thought: Henderson (1 scored 0 missed) Mané (1 scored 1 missed), Can (2 scored 3 missed) and Lallana (1 scored 0 missed). Added both Can and Lallana because if they’re fit to be at least in the bench and it goes to penalties there is a big chance that they’ll be on the pitch.
Just to add, looked at Karius and Migs statistics.
Mignolet: saved 12, not saved 32
Karius: saved 9, not saved 21