For what we forked out v what we got back is why I have him, and have hom so high. He wouldnt be near my worst ever players list ( I think)
Also these lists are just my own view defo open to debate, which is what I wsnt really.
He may not have been an instant hit but we know why Keane was kicked out after 6 months, and it was nothing to do with his ability or form. If every signing was judged after just 6 months, then anyone who didn't hit the ground running would be sold off. Fabinho, Robbo, Thiago, Keita etc.
I could fit any one if not all of El Zhar, Ngog, Nunez, Adam, Aquilani, Jovanovic, Traore, Diao, Aspas, Arphexad, Gonzalez or Vignal onto the list. So I don't know how you couldn't find a spot for any of them instead.