Automated offside in World Cup?

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/12098/12643330/world-cup-2022-qatar-tournament-to-feature-semi-automated-offside-technology-with-ball-sensors-and-cameras

How long before this comes into the Premier League?

Him across the water going to have a field day on this one. 

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/12098/12643330/world-cup-2022-qatar-tournament-to-feature-semi-automated-offside-technology-with-ball-sensors-and-cameras

How long before this comes into the Premier League?

Him across the water going to have a field day on this one. 

yes automating football is the way forward. These people in charge must be souless automatons . Football is about talking points trying to make it pure will kill parts of the game off

yes automating football is the way forward. These people in charge must be souless automatons.

Tim Vickery from BBC who does world football podcast said "all it is bunch of techno nerds with their toys ruining the game" and I tend to agree with it.

I like VAR to review plays that if a noticeable error is made (like player offside by a couple feet) but the obsession to have every decision correct (in the view of technology used) is just a but much.

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/12098/12643330/world-cup-2022-qatar-tournament-to-feature-semi-automated-offside-technology-with-ball-sensors-and-cameras

How long before this comes into the Premier League?

Him across the water going to have a field day on this one. 

Their intent on ruining the game we know as football Fck wits playing with their gadgets ,

When do they turn into the Terminator and start murdering the players, ref and rest of the crowd.

What's the problem? The goal of this is to speed up offside calls.

It's not a Sunday morning kickabout. The World Cup Finals is the biggest and most important competition in the world. Therefore it is right that we have as many correct decisions as possible, to determine who wins and who has to try again in 4 years time. As I said from the beginning I don't care how long it takes to get the right decision, however if the technology is that advanced now to reach correct calls sooner, I can't really see why anyone would moan about it.

This is 2022. If you still want the game at the highest levels to be reffed just as it was back in 1872 or even 1972, well sorry but it ain't happening.

What's the problem? The goal of this is to speed up offside calls.

It's not a Sunday morning kickabout. The World Cup Finals is the biggest and most important competition in the world. Therefore it is right that we have as many correct decisions as possible, to determine who wins and who has to try again in 4 years time. As I said from the beginning I don't care how long it takes to get the right decision, however if the technology is that advanced now to reach correct calls sooner, I can't really see why anyone would moan about it.

This is 2022. If you still want the game at the highest levels to be reffed just as it was back in 1872 or even 1972, well sorry but it ain't happening.

Because VAR is such a success!!

What's the problem? The goal of this is to speed up offside calls.

It's not a Sunday morning kickabout. The World Cup Finals is the biggest and most important competition in the world. Therefore it is right that we have as many correct decisions as possible, to determine who wins and who has to try again in 4 years time. As I said from the beginning I don't care how long it takes to get the right decision, however if the technology is that advanced now to reach correct calls sooner, I can't really see why anyone would moan about it.

This is 2022. If you still want the game at the highest levels to be reffed just as it was back in 1872 or even 1972, well sorry but it ain't happening.

what a load of f***in crap as usual. You wouldnt understand the purity and passion and emotion of football if it hit you smack in the face what a tosser

what a load of f***in crap as usual. You wouldnt understand the purity and passion and emotion of football if it hit you smack in the face what a tosser

Blar blar blar, or should it be Blah blah blah 

The more you respond to him the more he gets off on it.

Blar blar blar, or should it be Blah blah blah 

The more you respond to him the more he gets off on it.

He is still on his Rafa rant lord knows what Rafa did to him but Rafa should have done it harder

He is still on his Rafa rant lord knows what Rafa did to him but Rafa should have done it harder

I learned a long time ago not to take the bait he gives members    He even put a cream cake on the hook once, was sooooo tempted to nibble on it though. 

Because VAR is such a success!!

It is a success. So much so that even the Scots who laughed and mocked and dismissed it when it started down south, now are going to bring it in. Albeit only after the World Cup, but better late than never.

It is a success. So much so that even the Scots who laughed and mocked and dismissed it when it started down south, now are going to bring it in. Albeit only after the World Cup, but better late than never.

It hasn’t been a success, it’s fckin failed on numerous occasions, only you Fck off for a bit , when it fails , it does Fck all for the game kills goal celebration fans go to games for enjoyment and the buzz not to wait for some silly c**t to play with lines on a computer , Fck the sterile game you advocate so much

It hasn’t been a success, it’s fckin failed on numerous occasions, only you Fck off for a bit , when it fails ,

You know/read him as well as me. 

It hasn’t been a success, it kills goal celebration fans go to games for enjoyment and the buzz not the sterile game you advocate so much

I don't advocate a sterile game, whatever that's supposed to mean. I advocate the right decision made. There's simply way too much at stake, for the wrong decision to be allowed to stand, especially at the World Cup.

Fans go to watch their teams get results, as results are everything. Nobody said you can't celebrate goals, so you celebrate as much as you want. The goal still has to be checked so it complies with the laws of the game.

From the amount of wrong decisions corrected and the amount of new countries and confederations adopting it all the time, shows how much of a success it is.

I don't advocate a sterile game, whatever that's supposed to mean. I advocate the right decision made. There's simply way too much at stake, for the wrong decision to be allowed to stand, especially at the World Cup.

Fans go to watch their teams get results, as results are everything. Nobody said you can't celebrate goals, so you celebrate as much as you want. The goal still has to be checked so it complies with the laws of the game.

From the amount of wrong decisions corrected and the amount of new countries and confederations adopting it all the time, shows how much of a success it is.

Are you a Fck wit on purpose , you disappeared every time var fcked up only to pop up and spout you’re usuL sh*t and repetitiveness when they got it right , don’t know if you have been to any game couldn’t give a shiny one tbh but you come over as a know it  all righteous son of a bi*ch who  sucks the fckin oxygen out of the game , bet your some kind of fun in the ale house before a game .

I don't advocate a sterile game, whatever that's supposed to mean. I advocate the right decision made. There's simply way too much at stake, for the wrong decision to be allowed to stand, especially at the World Cup.

Fans go to watch their teams get results, as results are everything. Nobody said you can't celebrate goals, so you celebrate as much as you want. The goal still has to be checked so it complies with the laws of the game.

From the amount of wrong decisions corrected and the amount of new countries and confederations adopting it all the time, shows how much of a success it is.

as a Famous Manc poster once said blah blah blah blah blah.

It is a success. So much so that even the Scots who laughed and mocked and dismissed it when it started down south, now are going to bring it in. Albeit only after the World Cup, but better late than never.

Is it? Most match-goers would tell you it's anything but a success. It's pretty much completely killing off goal celebrations because you know what's coming next.

How the F**k is that a success?

Of course it's a success, which is why more leagues and tournaments have it. When you go to a game now, you accept that every goal will be checked. If you don't accept that, you don't have to go. Every game is sold out, so obviously match goers are willing to put up with what's coming next.

It doesn't make any difference whether it affects goal celebrations or not but from what I see anyway, every match goer celebrates just as they always did. There's a billion quid on the line in our league before you even talk about trophies, or in this case 2 years of blood sweat and tears, so the decision has to be correct. If the technology is available to confirm decisions faster, I cannot understand why anyone would object to that. Especially those who complain that they take too long atm.

It doesn't make any difference whether it affects goal celebrations or not but from what I see anyway, every match goer celebrates just as they always did.

Well I'm telling you as a seasie ticket holder who goes most games we F***ing don't!!

 

Well I'm telling you as a seasie ticket holder who goes most games we f**king don't!!

 

He's armchair fan at best so wouldn't know,  that's if he even supports you lot! 

Well I'm telling you as a seasie ticket holder who goes most games we F***ing don't!!

When we score, I see 50,000 fans celebrating, season ticket holders, the richest, the poorest, the VIPs, the hospitality, the locals, the newbies, the daytrippers, the lot, along with everyone else who isn't as lucky to be there on the day. That's what I see. That's just goals at our home games. I don't see anyone terrified of what you say is coming next. Which 9 times out of 10, is nothing to worry about.

When we score, I see 50,000 fans celebrating, season ticket holders, the richest, the poorest, the VIPs, the hospitality, the locals, the newbies, the daytrippers, the lot, along with everyone else who isn't as lucky to be there on the day. That's what I see. That's just goals at our home games. I don't see anyone terrified of what you say is coming next. Which 9 times out of 10, is nothing to worry about.

When we score I'm in the middle of it.

Stop chatting out of your arse!!

When we score I'm in the middle of it.

No, you said your celebrations are killed as you said you know what's coming next, while the rest of us are going mad, even though we all know its a provisional decision until the check is complete. VAR is established here now and we're not going back to human error and injustices every week, just so you can celebrate goals as you used to.

Whether you go to games or not, the VAR doesn't care either way. It's not there to kill your celebrations, it's there to see justice done on the spot. I'm already 100% confident that after this WC, there will be no complaints about the speed of offside decisions by VAR at the tournament, by those who can go to it and those who can't.

No, you said your celebrations are killed as you said you know what's coming next, while the rest of us are going mad, even though we all know its a provisional decision until the check is complete. VAR is established here now and we're not going back to human error and injustices every week, just so you can celebrate goals as you used to.

Whether you go to games or not, the VAR doesn't care either way. It's not there to kill your celebrations, it's there to see justice done on the spot. I'm already 100% confident that after this WC, there will be no complaints about the speed of offside decisions by VAR at the tournament, by those who can go to it and those who can't.

F**k off twisting words, you knew exactly what I meant armchair fan!!

F**k off twisting words, you knew exactly what I meant armchair fan!!

Why you talking to a bot? You like talking to machines.  There’s enough on betting websites without having them on here, granted it’s just the one but ones more than enough. 

Why you talking to a bot? You like talking to machines.  There’s enough on betting websites without having them on here, granted it’s just the one but ones more than enough. 

you calling a "Bot" are you going soft in your old age he is a F****** P****** and a total A********. Emotion is so much a part of going to the game and to see a goal ticked off because someone wears size 12 boots as apposed to size 8 is a killer. After a goal the emotion is instant and I think people are being robbed or even mugged by this crap endorsed only by idiots .

you calling a "Bot" are you going soft in your old age he is a F****** P****** and a total A********. Emotion is so much a part of going to the game and to see a goal ticked off because someone wears size 12 boots as apposed to size 8 is a killer. After a goal the emotion is instant and I think people are being robbed or even mugged by this crap endorsed only by idiots .

Bots don't have emotions, that's why the machine never agrees with us 

Bots don't have emotions, that's why the machine never agrees with us 

we have a whole season of it and the Corrupt WC mid season break to come. Maybe with automated Offsides they could couple this to assault rifles this way the offending attacker would be more careful

Emotion is a part of the game, but it doesn't pay the bills, or sort the winners from the losers at the end of the season. The results do that, so the results of games must be what they're supposed to be, according to the rules. 

You're not offside by a toe or a boot or a head or a shoulder, you're simply either offside or you're not. There's nothing to debate when it comes to the implementation of the offside law, it's factual. The new technology is not even waiting for the World Cup to come round. It's happening tomorrow at the Super Cup Final, and then it will be in the European Cup. So we will experience it ourselves sooner than anticipated.

The reality is that we can't have a game without rules, and they are there for a reason. You can celebrate goals any way you want but if you attend any of our games, you automatically accept that VAR will be in operation and may have to be used. And if you don't want that, then nobody is forcing you to show up. VAR is now in every major competition on the planet, because it (usually) works the way it's supposed to.