Interested to see the opinions here on this one.
So I had not seen the LOTR films properly till this year, I have watched the 3 main ones twice over now and while I appreciate they are pretty awesome, I am still a Star Wars (excluding 7,8 and 9) over LOTR type of guy, on top of that I would put Harry Potter ahead of LOTR too.
What do you all think?
The original star wars trilogy is still the best for me but that is probably linked to my age.
The other 2 are adapted from books. LOTR and Harry Potter books are more important to me than the films, this is especially true for LOTR. When watching the films there is always a feeling that it doesn't quite match the mental image I had when reading the book.
Star Wars and LOTR are way ahead of Harry Potter for me, again linked to my age. Harry Potter came to late for me to get attached to it like the other 2. Nostalgia for the things we enjoyed as children/teenagers is a big part of the enjoyment I have now, it's difficult to assess them rationally.
Logged