, it's a lame excuse to deviate his weaknesses and focus only on his strengths.
Alonso, Mascherano and Hamann all played DM roles, but done a lot more with their passing and authority while playing in that role.
I think you are misunderstanding the role.
Alonso wasn't a DM he was a Deep Lying Playmaker (a DLPM) like Pirlo.
In Milan, Pirlo needed Gattuso to do the running, pressing and put in the tackles for him. At Juve, Marchisio and Vidal did the same. In the Italian side De Rossi performs the same role when the other two aren't available.
Alonso needed to play alongside Hamann, Masch or Leiva for the same reason. At Real, Diarra and Khedeira and at Bayern, Lahm and Martinez protect him.
In terms of a defensive midfielder, Masch is a better tackler and Hamann was more mobile but in terms of overall play as a DM Leiva is equal to both of them with notably better positioning and distribution.
If you can find it, Gary Neville did an excellent analysis of his style when he showed how he kept YaYa Toure in his pocket at a time when he was rampaging through the rest of the league.
Glad to see him back.
Logged