There are many reasons why neither Russia or Qatar should host the world cup, but we are missing the main reason.... Supporters!! FIFA does not give a sh*t about the supporters who have to travel to these events. it is the same with UEFA and their hosting of the champions league in far flung stadiums that are a nightmare for people to get to.
Visas and cost will be a huge problem in Russia, as will the huge distances fans will have to travel between cities.
Russia and FIFA is a cosy match though. neither like freedom of the press. Putin can put an arm round Sepp and tell him that unlike that pesky free press in the UK, he does not have to worry about the Russian Media, as he has it all under control! Russia is one of the most corrupt countries in the world. Again FIFA can relate to this. Many decisions in Russia are done in secret, and with no accountability (see freedom of press) between a small hiarchy of people... again FIFA like this concept.
As for the middle east in june/july. my god fans will need to walk round with a drip in order not to de-hydrate. temps up to 50 degrees. Apparantlely the stadiums are going to be built with open roofs but have some completely tried and untested cooling system that pumps air into the stadium. This bid was considered very high risk in every way, so we have the right to ask.....how the F**k did they get it?
What mind set is there in FIFA, when the pre bid technical inspection goes to the bidding country, see's no stadiums at all, no fan base, has a tiny population, no lasting legacy, no footballing history and the presentation is just a set of space age pretty drawings giving details of a theoretical cooling technology, and the think, yeah...that's the one for us! and the government of Qatar will pay for the stadiums!! but excuse me, aren't governents not allowed to get involved in the running of football at national level. seems like it is ok when it suits FIFA.
I'm not saying England should have got it, but they had a very compelling case. Why set such high criteria for bids, and then vote for those countries that are the furthest away from meeting those criteria.
Spain and Holland/Belgium's bid was excellent, and yes the Spanish are also pissed off. They cannot understand the decision either!
as for Australia and the USA, they have even more reason to think this is a stitch up. they Have great stadiums, growing support, transport networks, hotels, places to eat. In fact all the same things that would make staging the world cup in those countries great for the supporters visiting, and the same can be said for Spain, Belgium/Holland and England.
All of the losing countries have another thing in common.. a free press and media and democracy (i know Russia does, but it's not exactly a model version).