Stephen Warnock to return on loan?

The difference between mash and warnock is that warnock has been given games and mash wasn't. He was good last season but so far this season has been very poor.

Warnock is a good fullback/wingback and if we arent going to invest on the squad right now i would say this is good business. He knows the club and what it means to play for this club I would welcome him back especially if it means bye bye to Konchesky.

I'd take him in a flash, I don't think he should have been sold in the first place, a good bit of business in my opinion, even if it is only till the end of the season, we need all the help we can get at the minute.

The best word i'd use to describe Warnock is 'reliable'. That's what we need right now. Was sad to see him go when he was shown the door, so yes, i'd have him back in a heartbeat, no hesitation whatsoever. Obviously he's not a long term solution but he would certainly improve the squad.

Never been a fan of him, always thought he was overrated by Liverpool fans cause he came through the youth ranks but right now, I'd gladly take him on loan. He's not spetacular but can do the job.

Then I would look for someone better in the summer.

If we bring in a quality winger in the window then this would compliment that.

If we bring in a quality winger in the window then this would compliment that.

well said, yin + yang = Harmony.

He's better than Konchesky and Insua put together so why not.

If this is true, it's not much of a risk considering it will be a loan deal. If it works out then great, if not, he'll go back to Villa. Well worth the (not very big) risk in my opinion.

 I'm 50-50 at the moment about this. While I've doubts about his ability, I think he's better than Konchesky, but considering it's only a loan deal until the end of the season then ok.
 Edit: One thing I read these days that was really bad news for us was we can't sell Konchesky because he can't play for three different PL teams in 1 season. Don't think anyone abroad is interested in him, so he'll be with us at least until the end of this season.

F**k Warnock, he isn't football player who has quality. We want Taye Taiwo and we could bring him for free on the summer.

So your problem with another player coming in on loan until the summer is what then. How will a summer target help us now Haris

To be honest I was surprised we let him go in the first place.

Good player and actually underrated. Was very disappointed when Rafa sold him in the first place but he's a very solid full back and worthy of a place in the Liverpool team. And it means Konchesky slips down the pecking order. Aurelio gets injured too much and judging on what I've seen the past year and a half I don't want to fall back on Insua or Konchesky just yet. Although Insua can still have a future at the club unlike Konchesky.

Far better than Konchesky, more reliable than Insua, probably not as injury prone as Aurelio.

Not really world class but... ^^

A loan would be ideal imo.

very good move imo as konk and insua are sh*te so depending on money we got to spend can go on attacking players

So your problem with another player coming in on loan until the summer is what then. How will a summer target help us now Haris

In that case we could buy Ajax's Erby Emanuelson (contract expires in summer 2011) and then we dont need to buy Taiwo.

Tawio is twice the player of Emamuelson.

Except our resident dutch expert reckons he is not the solution either

Never understood why we let him go to be honest,thought he was alright solid and reliable,win win situation if ged doesnt want him then why not?

I dont understand how a number of posters think warnock should not have been sold on, he came back from two broken legs and needed game time, so if he was not good enough for rafa's first team he also is not good enough for houlliers first team and lets remember warnock and houllier dont see eye to eye, however he cant be worse that what we have got already.

In that case we could buy Ajax's Erby Emanuelson (contract expires in summer 2011) and then we dont need to buy Taiwo.

Ok, so when are you going to start making sense? First in response to getting Warnock on loan till the summer you say no let's get Taiwo in the summer on a free, that'll help us alot now. Then when being called out on that you say well let's get Emanuelson then because his contract expires this summer. What?! Why not just get Taiwo now then? Emanuelson isn't even as good as Warnock, let alone Taiwo. Why would you want Emanuelson, please explain? Guess who hasn't even been the first choice left back for Ajax this and last season? Indeed, Emanuelson. But, enlighten me.

Right on queue Dex. Good man.