Well I don't really see how what I said was so controversial... When you say that what I said was he was "unfit" for the job, it makes me think, "such and such manager is totally incompetent and has no idea what he is doing and should become a plumber or something." That's not what I think or ever thought about Rodgers. What I said in that post and what he showed at many points last season was the mentality of a small club manager---going up 2-0 away when you are bossing a team and then deciding to park the bus. That is a small time tactic. No one can deny that. Oh and at that point last season we were also just a few points off 4th. So it was a huge game. Does anyone here deny that is a small-club tactic? of course not.
So yes. He looked way out of his league. He was trying to bring small club tactics to a team that should be winning. You translate this as being "unfit" for the job, I say it's not being right or not being ready. And there was nothing to show last season that he was right or ready for the job. So FSG took a risk and stuck with him and now we are 4 wins away from winning the league. It was a gamble that paid off. Exponentially.
I think the issue is: I am/was just so damn tired of us losing, year after year after year. And I think I might have punched someone if I heard that stupid phrase "work in progress" one more time. That was the get out of jail free card for us to lose and draw and play awfully. But yea, maybe I'm missing something but I don't really see how what I said last season changes anything. If you look at us now and last year, we play almost nothing like we were doing when he first came. We're playing more counter-attacking football than the "Barcelona lite" that he was trying to have us do. We are playing with a diamond FFS. These things come directly from the manager---so clearly he himself knew that what he was trying to do last season wasn't working. And clearly he realized that the small-club approach wasn't going to get us titles.
Anyway, this whole "gotcha" thing is a bit weird. I stand by what I said---that Rodgers at the time was way out of his league. But obviously with a year under his belt, he has learned a hell of a lot and his learning curve has brought us to where we are. It's almost like we have 2 different managers, one last season and one this season. And, as I said, since we are basically playing with the same starting XI as last season, the changes have to be credited to him.
I just don't get why with us, it is always about F***ing waiting. Waiting on Rodgers to learn the ropes. Waiting 2 years on Henderson to start to show his potential. Waiting about a year longer than we should have on Carroll to get rid. Waiting waiting waiting. Suarez came in and BAM right away showed what he was all about. As did Coutinho.
Oh well.
Logged