Difficult one this, both sides were/are very good and you could make a good argument for both hence the debate, but I think the telling difference is the managers, so for this reason I'm going our current unfinished X1,
It has been mentioned above about how Klopp's record in finals isn't the best, I can't remember too many finals we reached under TPM, and it's safe to say we will be in a few more under Jürgen,
So I'm in the 16/17 camp.
YNWA
Logged