Nicolas Anelka

Anelka has put in a transfer request request today (3/12/11) just in time for the Winter transfer window.
Would you have him back at Anfield?

Don't think so. On the wane I feel and I don't think he should ever have left for Chelsea nearly 4 years ago now. Had a very good career though. Never really disappointed. Always that feeling he had unfinished business at Liverpool but for a complete horror decision by Houllier a decision so bad that I think it contributed to Liverpool's decline under the Frenchman.

I'd take him, always scored goals and a different option to our other forwards.

Might have done at one time, not sure I would now, he's passed his best.

Let him slip through our hands.
Massive mistake at the time.
How old is he now?

. Passed his best defo no from me. Anelka wants to leave because he is not playing do people think he would be happy to sit on the bench here

Out of curiosity, I thought the "winter transfer board" was about players linked to Liverpool. I know he's handed in a transfer request but he's not been linked to us.

Anyway, I think he could be a player who could offer us something. He has pace, can find a goal, and can play on the right, or up front so he's versatile.

I would bring him in, but I wouldn't sign him, too much of a risk and he's declining. But I wouldn't mind bringing him on loan till the end of the season, could be a key player who could get us a few goals and a different approach to our game.

I wouldn't sign him, his wages and signing on fee would be way too dear for me but I'd definately bring him on loan, if it's a viable alternative.

He's 32 now so he is getting on in footballing terms.

Massive mistake to not sign him when we had the chance a few years ago, he's currently declining to rapidly but I do believe that he could offer us something if we could get him on loan.

Let him slip through our hands.
Massive mistake at the time.
How old is he now?

32 I think.

Might have done at one time, not sure I would now, he's passed his best.

Couldn't the same be said of G. Mac at the time?

Couldn't the same be said of G. Mac at the time?

Very true....but I think in our current situation, we have enough in the present squad and upcoming youngsters to not need him and I'm still confident that Carroll will come good, given time.

Always been a class player and still is. I wanted him to be included in the Torres deal last year. That made far more sense to me than shelling the huge fee on Carroll and my opinion hasn't changed with hindsight. Still a quality player for me but if the club went for him they would essentially be saying "Andy you're not good enough" so I don't think it will happen. As for the age factor, isn't Bellamy the same age? That wouldn't bother me a bit.

Great player in his day absolutely unplayable when he was at Arsenal, I'd take that Anelka tomorrow, the current one though, I'd rather pass.

Not for me, he is in rapid decline IMO.

 I never understood why Houllier never signed him when he had the chance but I am afraid I would give him a miss today.

He's very probably going to China, he's heavily linked with Shangai club (talks confirmed by his agent).

rather have drogba on loan

He should have been signed by Houllier but now he is past his best and I'm not sure leaving Chelsea's bench for ours is what he is after.

Probably off to Middle East or the US.

No. Agree with Corbally here.

No, definitely no from me. Would of liked him to stay back when we had him on loan but his career is too close to over and his level of performance is well on it's way down. Simple decision this one.

I don't think it's a goer either but everyone a bit too quick to write the guy off I think. He played well last year but AVB doesn't seem to like him so he doesn't play much now. I'm sure he's got a bit more in his locker.

I don't think it's a goer either but everyone a bit too quick to write the guy off I think. He played well last year but AVB doesn't seem to like him so he doesn't play much now. I'm sure he's got a bit more in his locker.

He probably has mate but he's heading to the wrong side of 30 along with Doni, Kuyt, Bellamy, Gerrrard, Carragher and Maxi, who we already have in our squad, I wouldn't sign him as the knock on effects of letting the average age of the squad rise unchecked can be seen clearly at Chelsea.

He mentioned on his twitter that he knows where he will be in january. Caughtoffside has linked him with us, I know caughtoffside isn't the best source but they are saying fees could be as low as 4 million.

He will always score goals - and if god forbid anything happens to Suarez he is good backup... But why would he want to go from one bench to another? If he comes here and kicks off, which he very well could then no thank's..

We should have kept him years ago - but alas... For me its 50 / 50 - either way I would be happy. If Kenny thinks he can do a job for us then give him a go...

I'd have him here for the rest of the season and take it from there. Anelka is the same age as Bellamy and look how good he's been for us this season. If Kenny could do the same for him then we could have that extra spark upfront to push on for a top four finish.