Couldn't agree more fella, think you and I share a very similar opinion on Can in that he'd make the perfect box-to-box midfielder, it's just that it's clear Brendan is going to use him in that role having already informed his national coach the same, so basically I'm accepting this for the time being.
Even the great Jan Molby feels the same way
Can on the other hand looks capable of certainly filling the box-to-box role and also adapting to the DLPM role but as a pure DM I think he might get exposed. There's less chance of this with Milner and Henderson ahead of him as both are extremely diligent and are unlikely to leave him exposed.
As for the DLPM, I see where you are coming from, especially how he likes to play those long or medium balls into the wide areas, or diagonal balls into forward runners, but I believe a DLPM is similar to a DM role, so either role, Can for me will get exposed if our box-box players are not disciplined enough. And also, I prefer my DLPM's to be dictators (pass masters) on the ball.
I do believe in playing these 3 together though we sacrifice a lot in terms of creativity and having to play Coutinho from the wide area but I'm much happier seeing that formation than the one that started against Stoke.
On paper, I don't like it, but we have yet to see it functional live, so whilst I'm apprehensive about them playing together, I'm also excited and curious to see what Rodgers has in store when he plays the trio.
Creativity wise, I agree, we could lose out a lot especially if Firmino and Coutinho are shafted out wide, but I think it'll be ok if we play the 442 diamond and have Firmino support Benteke so he doesn't become isolated with Coutinho #10.
I would have no problems (personally) opting for Can & Milner/Henderson as the further forward midfielders
I would have Can, Hendo and Milner to battle it out for the 2 box-box roles in a 442 diamond with Allen as 4th choice.
I think Can could play deeper, not quite as well just yet at reading the game from there like Lucas
It's the short passing that worries me mostly about Can if he does play deeper. Yes, he has composure on the ball and is a wonderful ball carrier, but if you look at the exceptional or world class DM/DLPM's, what really sets them apart is their ability to keep the ball ticking and manipulate the play, something Can can not do but Lucas can.
Logged