If I was Rafa....
Seen enough - To leave Anfield this summer...
Dudek - consistent keeper - consistently dodgy
Fowler - too much competition for the old boy
Crouch - nice hat-trick but not going to land us a title
Bellamy - not prolific enough
Pennant - out of his depth
Kewell - if anyone will have him
Sissoko - could provide some valuable back at Anfield. Mascherano similar player but with better distribution
Garcia - not been missed while injured. Goes missing too many times. Needs to be replaced however.
Zenden.
Last chance saloon - another season
Gonzalez - new country, young lad, flashes of brilliance - one more season
Hyypia - almost replaced by Agger - needed for central defensive cover
Riise - neither a world class left back or world class left midfielder - but until he is replaced provides us with options, for sure
Kuyt - we want some more goals next year Dirky
Blimey Jabba, I'm glad you're not my boss! I'd be sacked in days!
Seriously though, I'd say that's a few too many changes to be making in one season. I agree with your sentiments regarding most of them, but wouldn't say they're reasons a lot of them should go, rather reasons they should only be squad players.
We're never gonna be Sh!tski, with two quality players for each position. Rather we need to focus on getting quality first teamers, and keeping the players on board that aren't world class but who we can 'make do' with if the first choice isn't playing. The players I would expect to go are:
Dudek - Carson will come back next season, and we will probably sign Padelli permanantly as well. No need for him.
Fowler - Unfortunately hasn't looked after his body as well as others in the game. Won't be up to playing 90 minutes, so needs to go for me.
Zenden - If anyone thinks he should stay, I would ask you to PM me with all your credit card details, you are obviously that stupid you would do it.
Kewell - I don't care how good he is when he's fit, he never is fit. Simple as.
The other players that have been mantioned, Hyypia, Riise, Garcia, Crouch, Bellamy & Pennant, are all good enough to be squad players IMO, but none of them should be first choice in their positions. Hyypia, Garcia & Crouch aren't first choices already, but the introduction of Aurelio at LB, and if we buy a new right winger & striker, would see a large reduction in the number of games the others play next season.