Your combined team of Liverpool, Man City, Spurs and Villa.

With us competing for 4th with these other 3 teams, I just want to see what combined team we can come up with and how many Liverpool players would make it. 

Who really gives a sh*t about the other teams.

Who really gives a sh*t about the other teams.

Just interested on how our fans will pick this team and what Liverpool players will be left out.

One of the more pointless threads on these boards.

                   Reina
Johnson   Carra   Agger   Aurelio
                    Masch
Maxi/Kuyt Gerrard Aquilani  Yossi/Maxi
                    Nando

That's good enough fo me.

WTF..

Someday we'll see a thread for Rafa's Fart.

Not a good topic.
There are no other teams than Liverpool..........are there?

ok... lets try

Reina
Bale Agger Dunne Johnson
Maxi Gerrard Masch Kuyt
Nando Pav

Why is this such a bad thread?!

There are other players in all those teams which we could do with, what's the problem?

I'd have:

                                     Reina
Johnson          Dunne                 Agger             Bale

Milner             Gerrard               Masch             Maxi

                      Torres                 Tevez

Subs: Given, Kuyt, Carra, Modric, Crouch, Kazakhstaniagos, Aqualani

                   Reina
Johnson   Carra   Agger   Aurelio
                    Masch
Maxi/Kuyt Gerrard Aquilani  Yossi/Maxi
                    Nando


 

That's good enough fo me.

So what your saying is struggling for 4th is good enough for you?

Why is this such a bad thread?!

There are other players in all those teams which we could do with, what's the problem?

I'd have:

                                     Reina
Johnson          Dunne                 Agger             Bale

Milner             Gerrard               Masch             Maxi

                      Torres                 Tevez

Subs: Given, Kuyt, Carra, Modric, Crouch, Kazakhstaniagos, Aqualani

not one of the best threads around .

but maxi in ahead of ashley young?

                             Reina

Johnson       Carragher      Agger        Aurelio

Maxi         Mascherano    Gerrard       Benayoun

                         Aquilani

                         Torres



                               Reina

Johnson       Dunne             Agger           Bale

Young         Mascherano     Gerrard          Milner

                 Torres           Tevez

I don't want Tevez or his neck on my team, and if I were to pick and choose players from all 4 teams....I would just pick Liverpool players because the rest can s*ck it.

So what your saying is struggling for 4th is good enough for you?

If Gerrard would of performed like last season and Torres wouldn't have so many injuries, do you really think that we would be fighting for 4th place?

I'd have Bridge only due to our left-back problems. I'd also have Tevez. I'd also have Milner. De Jong as back up to Mascherano. I would have Barry aswell.

Actually quite an interesting  and refreshing post mate, qudos.
I'm not going to specualte cos i am biased through and through , but it shows that the competition around us much stronger than us in some areas of the pitch, that our player superiority over these teams in the past has narrowed severley.

Pepe
Glen Skrtel Agger Bale
Maxi Masch Gerrard Babel
Defoe Torres

I'd have Bridge only due to our left-back problems. I'd also have Tevez. I'd also have Milner. De Jong as back up to Mascherano. I would have Barry aswell.

Just too many to choose from if you ask me

Last season, Ireland was immense. His passing were sublime! Even Agbonlahor would do a good job as a subsitute!

Alot of people forget that Gareth Bale has been sh*t for spurs but because he's had a good run of games in the second half of this season, all of a sudden he's amazing.

He's still in my dodgy books.

I don't want Tevez or his neck on my team, and if I were to pick and choose players from all 4 teams....I would just pick Liverpool players because the rest can s*ck it.

That is a retarded statement to make in all fairness ! are you saying if we signed gareth barry last summer you'd tell him to suck it ?, or when we signed Bellamy,or Keane ? Pure stupidity...

My team        Reina

Johnson       Agger   Dunne   Bale

Milner    Mascherano   Modric Young

                   Gerrard
                        
                          Torres

And the bench:Given,Carragher ,Tevez ,Maxi,Aqualiani
 

If Gerrard would of performed like last season and Torres wouldn't have so many injuries, do you really think that we would be fighting for 4th place?

no....but I also think that naming the whole Liverpool team is stupid. Are you saying players like Tevez, Barry, Lennon, Milner, Young, Dunne, wudnt make our team?

I'm not a big fan of Dunne to be honest, If I had to pick a Center Back from one of the other teams, it would be Michael Dawson or Ledley King.

I'm not a big fan of Dunne to be honest, If I had to pick a Center Back from one of the other teams, it would be Michael Dawson or Ledley King.

As an Irishman I'm going to disagree. I dont think Dunne gets the credit he deserves at times. Although I'd take Dawson before him because he is probably as good, younger and the potential to become very good.

So what your saying is struggling for 4th is good enough for you?

But your team are second atm, no mate???

Jesus Christ, you start a thread and don't even give your own opinion in the OP! Nearly everyone of your posts have been anti Liverpool or been talking up other sides! Your cluelessness knows no bounds! Firstly, your expectation of Nemeth to be the next Messi! Then your obsession with the little judas himself! Followed by threads about our rivals, trying to degrade the redmen! I think you should leave now, your cover's up mate... Here, I think you're lost: http://www.redcafe.net/register.php

Don't let the door hit you on the way out!

But your team are second atm, no mate???

Jesus Christ, you start a thread and don't even give your own opinion in the OP! Nearly everyone of your posts have been anti Liverpool or been talking up other sides! Your cluelessness knows no bounds! Firstly, your expectation of Nemeth to be the next Messi! Then your obsession with the little judas himself! Followed by threads about our rivals, trying to degrade the redmen! I think you should leave now, your cover's up mate... Here, I think you're lost: http://www.redcafe.net/register.php

Don't let the door hit you on the way out!

You did not read my Nemeth thing correctly. And no my posts are not anti Liverpool posts and yes I did give an opinion on this thread. My obsession with the little Judas???  I said he had won a Ballon D'or at 21. If you go through all my posts, I think you'll find that I really love this football club and I give an honest assesement on what I see.. And if thats negative at the moment then sorry ...

You did not read my Nemeth thing correctly. And no my posts are not anti Liverpool posts and yes I did give an opinion on this thread. My obsession with the little Judas???  I said he had won a Ballon D'or at 21. If you go through all my posts, I think you'll find that I really love this football club and I give an honest assesement on what I see.. And if thats negative at the moment then sorry ...

There you go stirring again! I READ YOUR POST PERFECTLY! You didn't express yourself eloquently enough! Remember, no? Here, just to remind you kiddo: http://www.lfcreds.com/reds/index.php?topic=29181.25

You admit that: "And I didnt explain myself properly about the whole Ballon D'or thing..sorry...Dont expect that"! So, start apologising again matE!

Ya I didnt....Dont want to argue anymore. Especially with Liverpool fan so leave it at that..

One from each ...
Bale's had a great season. Tidy finisher too, he could play full back or on the wing, versatile.
Milner is strong and a decent finisher. Rarely seems to get injured, reliable.
Teves must be giving Fergie nightmares - must be their player of the year. De Jong's been good in midfield.
To pick someone outside Torres, SG and Reina - I like Glen Johnson. Might not be as solid in defense as some others, but super going forward.

That is a retarded statement to make in all fairness ! are you saying if we signed gareth barry last summer you'd tell him to suck it ?, or when we signed Bellamy,or Keane ? Pure stupidity...

My team        Reina

Johnson       Agger   Dunne   Bale

Milner    Mascherano   Modric Young

                   Gerrard
                         
                          Torres

And the bench:Given,Carragher ,Tevez ,Maxi,Aqualiani
 

I am saying why are we discussing this topic? My point was I don't care about who isn't on the team I care about who is on the team. Thanks btw for the karma, I really appreciated it.

Reina

Johnson Agger Carragher Bale

Maxi Mascherano Gerrard Babel
     
    Torres     Tevez

Would love to see that line up ever!

                                    Reina

Johnson            Toure            Agger           Bridge

                              Mascherano

                      Gerrard              Modric

     Tevez                                              Robinho
                                Torres

Bench:
Given
Carragher
Lescott
Milner
Young
Defoe
Adebayor

Robinho is in Brazil.

but still a city player.

                   Reina
Johnson - Sotis - Agger - Bale
Modric - Gerrard - Mascherano - Milner
             Torres - Tevez

Given, Young, Palacios, Aquilani, Adebayor, Carragher, De Jong on the bench.


A bit pointless thread but got me thinking for a while.

It's not the pointless / pathetic thread that some of you are suggesting when you consider that many of the players doing well at those clubs are players that many Liverpool fans would have liked us to have signed at some point, Barry, Milner, Tevez, Young, Lennon to name a few.
It's a bit harsh to slate someone for asking your opinions when others will write lengthy posts on here purely to attack an individual player.
Not the worst thread by a long way.

I personally quite like Monobrow's selection but agree with imcfitz that Ashley Young should be in Maxi's place and I would still find room for Yossi and Skrtel on the bench.

I'd probably have Tevez, Wayne Bridge and maybe Defoe.

But that's about it.

                   Reina

Johnson - Skrtel - Agger - Bale

      Gerrard - Masch - Milner

      Tevez - Torres - Bellamy

Bench: Given, Carra, Bridge, Kuyt, Defoe, Modric, Young.

Lennon, Bale, Defoe, Tevez, Milner, Modric would all be worth looking at.

Friedel

Zabaleta---Agger--King---Bridge

Young---Milner---Gerrard---Bale/Modric

Torres---Scarface

Are you sure you are a Liverpool fan, no Masch Johnson Reina(Friedel instead of Reina what are you on)

Friedel

Zabaleta---Agger--King---Bridge

Young---Milner---Gerrard---Bale/Modric

Torres---Scarface

Surprised it took this long for someone to mention Zabaleta. I think he's great, personally.

                   Reina

Zabaleta   Sotis   Agger    Aurelio

        Mascherano    Gerrard

 Milner         Modric        Young

                  Torres

I reckon that'd wipe the floor.

Are you sure you are a Liverpool fan, no Masch Johnson Reina(Friedel instead of Reina what are you on)

I think his user name gives it away "Benitezsuckswilly"


                                 Reina

Johnson          Toure           Agger            Bridge

Gerrard            Masch         Huddlestone   Milner

                       Torres         Tevez

Given
Carra
Skrtel
Bale
Modric
Young
Defoe

Zabletta is F***ing average at best, he is as slow as sh*t and sh*te going forward, jaysus the only lad to agree with you crouch there is a lad obviously here on a piss take.

Zabletta is F***ing average at best, he is as slow as sh*t and sh*te going forward, jaysus the only lad to agree with you crouch there is a lad obviously here on a piss take.

Cool.

F**k me I wouldn't mind Richards has played more for City at right back this season than Zabletta, I've obviously annoyed you with your response.

F**k me I wouldn't mind Richards has played more for City at right back this season than Zabletta, I've obviously annoyed you with your response.

Can't be that obvious if you think 'cool' = 'ARGH!H!!WEFWGRGAGAVG@@@@$%@$%#$ERFG'

Zabaleta is a pretty solid player. Great cross, can beat a man, can tackle and defend, is versatile and really impressed me when he played for Argentina at the Olympics.

Zabletta has been fairly average at best Crouch for City, his bonus is mostly he is a versatile player. No where near Johnson as an out an out right back. City would snap your hand off for a straight swop

Zabletta isn't anything special.

Johnson and corluka are far better.

                          REINA

JOHNSON        DAWSON       AGGER         BALE

LENNON          MODRIC        GERRARD       YOUNG

                     TEVEZ          TORRES

Surprised to read Dunne mentioned so often - highly over-rated IMO
(sorry, but I'm going to include Everton players in mine)

                       Reina

Johnson   Jagielka     Agger     Warnock (Bale can't defend)

Milner/Arteta    Masch       Gerrard    Modric

         Tevez     Agbonglahor

I've got the worse feeling I'm missing someone out..........

I thought this was the teams fighting for 4th ^

Jagielka plays for Everton :/

I thought this was the teams fighting for 4th ^

Jagielka plays for Everton :/

I know but the rest of the central defenders I could think of are average and I think Arteta is outstanding

Surprised to read Dunne mentioned so often - highly over-rated IMO
(sorry, but I'm going to include Everton players in mine)

                       Reina

Johnson   Jagielka     Agger     Warnock (Bale can't defend)

Milner/Arteta    Masch       Gerrard    Modric

         Tevez     Agbonglahor

I've got the worse feeling I'm missing someone out..........

Ya the best striker in the world mate

Reina

Johnson Agger  Dawson Bale

Milner Modric Stevie Young

Torres  Tevez


Given Toure King Lennon Masch Defoe Bellamy

Not going to pick a team out of this lot but I've watched Bale a number of times for his country, he's an excellent footballer but nowhere near being a left back. Think Spurs have started playing him in his strongest posistion, left midfielder...just suprised its taken redknapp this long to work it out.

Mark my words .....he'll be a Spurs left midfield legend! (unless we can snap him up in the summer  )

                     Reina
   Corluka   Sotis      Agger    Bridge
                    Masch
        Lennon              Young
                    Gerrard
             Torres         Tevez

Given, , Skrtel, Barry, Maxi, Milner, Bellamy, Defoe on the bench.

Looking at that team, the middle is pretty much all Liverpool but nothing on the wings. Still think that's our mainproblem. Pace and trickery at the byeline.

Can;t believe that some people are actually contributing to this thread , who gives a toss.

                                                          Riena


                                Johnson       Agger         Skrtel       Bale



                                Milner         Macherano    Gerrard    Young


                                                  Torres         Defoe


Subs  


Gomez

Carragher
Insua

Ireland
Modric

Tevez
Yossi
        

With us competing for 4th with these other 3 teams, I just want to see what combined team we can come up with and how many Liverpool players would make it.  

But your team are second atm, no mate???

Jesus Christ, you start a thread and don't even give your own opinion in the OP! Nearly everyone of your posts have been anti Liverpool or been talking up other sides! Your cluelessness knows no bounds! Firstly, your expectation of Nemeth to be the next Messi! Then your obsession with the little judas himself! Followed by threads about our rivals, trying to degrade the redmen! I think you should leave now, your cover's up mate... Here, I think you're lost: http://www.redcafe.net/register.php

Don't let the door hit you on the way out!

So come on then.
Whats your idea of L Equipe De bas**rds ?

Well I started it because there are players at the other 3 clubs that we could and should buy IF we are to get the funding and I wanted to see what players people would put ahead of ours. Its not really that pointless imo.   

Reina
Johnson Dawson Agger Warnock
Lennon Gerrard Milner Modric
Tevez Torres

Would LOVE to see Warnock back at club...

                     Reina

Johnson  Carragher   Agger    Bridge

        Mascherano    Gerrard

 Young                               Babel

            Torres     Tevez

Only 3 players!

                     Reina

Johnson  Carragher   Agger    Bridge

        Mascherano    Gerrard

 Young                               Babel

            Torres     Tevez

Only 3 players!

Sorry but Bridge 

Sorry but Bridge 

Who would you pick i wouldnt mind him on my team either

Who would you pick I wouldnt mind him on my team either

Bridge hasn't had a decent season since before Chelsea - slow, lacks a positional sense, no longer effective in attack - I would easily take Insua over him.
I put Warnock as my LB however

Dunno why some are saying this is a pointless thread. Fact is, we are behind these teams and they have been getting some damn good performances from some of those players, so if we could get some of them i would not mind at all. Would give my left nut to have Tevez perform the way he has for shitty for us, he has been immense.

Ihatemancs needs to have a nice warm cup of calm-the-F**k-down as well. Thats coming from someone who drinks them often

Who would you pick I wouldnt mind him on my team either

Emiliano Insua! The lad's quality and the reason why we got rid of Warnock in the first place! It's just a minor blip in form! Don't worry!

Anyways, I'm surprised this thread is still open and the mong who started it is still here!

Emiliano Insua! The lad's quality and the reason why we got rid of Warnock in the first place! It's just a minor blip in form! Don't worry!

Anyways, I'm surprised this thread is still open and the mong who started it is still here!

if its so bad then why are you wasting your time giving an opinion on it??

if its so bad then why are you wasting your time giving an opinion on it??

To state my shock! For instance, if we lost 5-0 in a match, would you not post in the after match thread, just to slag off Liverpool players, and say how sh*t we are compared to Villa, Spurs, City! And your personal favourites: United!

To state my shock! For instance, if we lost 5-0 in a match, would you not post in the after match thread, just to slag off Liverpool players, and say how sh*t we are compared to Villa, Spurs, City! And your personal favourites: United!

Just leave it, mate.

Will you please show me my comments that justify all of this stuff your saying?? I mentioned Owen won a personal award!! THAT IS IT!!! I have also never said we are sh*t compared to Villa, Spurs and City??
You have got the wrong end of it when it comes to me and questioning my support for Liverpool mate     
And comparing ourselves to our nearsest rivals on this thread is not pointless 

Will you please show me my comments that justify all of this stuff your saying?? I mentioned Owen won a personal award!! THAT IS IT!!! I have also never said we are sh*t compared to Villa, Spurs and City??
You have got the wrong end of it when it comes to me and questioning my support for Liverpool mate     
And comparing ourselves to our nearsest rivals on this thread is not pointless 

OK, if you're not a Manc, you're definitely one of those sh*t fans who has never and never will be anywhere near Anfield! I am positive just from the general tone of shitness from you're posts that you have never been to Anfield! Am I correct or wide off the mark again! ? I can smell your type a mile away mate! Go on as a truthful fellow Scouser, answer my question! How many times have you been there son?

OK, if you're not a Manc, you're definitely one of those sh*t fans who has never and never will be anywhere near Anfield! I am positive just from the general tone of shitness from you're posts that you have never been to Anfield! Am I correct or wide off the mark again! ? I can smell your type a mile away mate! Go on as a truthful fellow Scouser, answer my question! How many times have you been there son?

Ive never been for a match there, nor have many of us here. What does that have to with being a fan of the club? If you dare go down the "not a true fan" road you'll be in trouble.

Ive never been for a match there, nor have many of us here. What does that have to with being a fan of the club? If you dare go down the "not a true fan" road you'll be in trouble.

Not sayin that mate, I'm just saying he's been giving it out big in a few other threads, making fun of people's threads, when his posts have been quite poor also! I.E, "Trying to act the top red!"

I know plenty of diehard fans that have never been to Anfield and I also know plenty of fans who still think Heskey is Ryan Babel and who have been to Anfield many times.. And I can guarantee I am more of a fan than you will ever be. You have only 19 posts on this and I would say ten of them have been accusing me of being a Manc. So why dont you concentrate on talking on the the threads rather than questionning me. I also have my suspicions that I know who you are and your just taking the pi*s but I'll hold my judgement on that

Not sayin that mate, I'm just saying he's been giving it out big in a few other threads, making fun of people's threads, when his posts have been quite poor also! I.E, "Trying to act the top red!"

Alright good, just making sure

Anyways, going a bit off topic here guys.

I know plenty of diehard fans that have never been to Anfield and I also know plenty of fans who still think Heskey is Ryan Babel and who have been to Anfield many times.. And I can guarantee I am more of a fan than you will ever be. You have only 19 posts on this and I would say ten of them have been accusing me of being a Manc. So why dont you concentrate on talking on the the threads rather than questionning me. I also have my suspicions that I know who you are and your just taking the pi*s but I'll hold my judgement on that

You know who I am? Is that some sort of F***ing threat or something? A bigger Liverpool fan than me? Really... Haha ok mate, keep thinking that son! I've had relations killed at Hillsborough! I've protested against the Yanks! I've offered thousands of pounds to share liverpool fc just to get the club back on the right track! I've paid over 2 grand, nearly 2 months wages to get to European finals in the last 5 years! I have sacrificed so much for this club! You do not have the right to question me mate!

You know who I am? Is that some sort of f**king threat or something? A bigger Liverpool fan than me? Really... Haha ok mate, keep thinking that son! I've had relations killed at Hillsborough! I've protested against the Yanks! I've offered thousands of pounds to share liverpool fc just to get the club back on the right track! I've paid over 2 grand, nearly 2 months wages to get to European finals in the last 5 years! I have sacrificed so much for this club! You do not have the right to question me mate!

Ahem.
 

Any person that comes on here and uses the Hillsborough Disaster as a means of justifying themselves as a fan is sick.. If that is true then I'm very sorry mate but because someone related to you at Hillsborough died, does not make you any bigger of a fan than anyone else?
And why are 90% of your comments on this questioning me?
You have 21 posts and roughly 15 of them are comments against me?
And by me saying I know who you are is not a threat. I just think that you must be on a wind up because how many people on this forum spend 90% of their time giving out.
I would also say something but you are the only person on this who has any problem with any of my posts.

Ahem.
 

I'm just defending myself against the dude with the attitude problem.

I'm just defending myself against the dude with the attitude problem.

Personal Messages mate, just keep it clean.

ok...back on topic.

I'd go for:

Reina
Johnson, Carra, Agger, Bale
Lennon, Masch, Gerrard, Milner
Torres, Tevez.

Subs: Given, Dawson, Modric, Defoe, Bellamy, Kranjar, Richards

Pretty versatile and attacking match day squad I'd say.

Any person that comes on here and uses the Hillsborough Disaster as a means of justifying themselves as a fan is sick.. If that is true then I'm very sorry mate but because someone related to you at Hillsborough died, does not make you any bigger of a fan than anyone else?
And why are 90% of your comments on this questioning me?
You have 21 posts and roughly 15 of them are comments against me?
And by me saying I know who you are is not a threat. I just think that you must be on a wind up because how many people on this forum spend 90% of their time giving out.
I would also say something but you are the only person on this who has any problem with any of my posts.

, I've seen plenty of posts against you! Namely in this thread! And two or three more in different threads! The reason, I've taken it up with you, is because I think you're a Manc and I hate em'! Good enough for ya!? As for the Hillsborough thing! I'm trying to get it into you're little brain that I'm ingrained in this club's history more than you ever will be!!!

There I've said my piece!

Personally I don't see the difference in this thread to speculating over which players we would love to sign in the future from other clubs. At the end of the day players come and go and there are definitely players in our top 4 rival's team that would be great to have at Liverpool.

Fair play if it was the "Which players from Everton and Manchester United do you wish we could have in LFC" thread but it isn't so I can't see the problem? Why is at least one person going on a full on vendetta?!

By the way I forgot Lennon in my team, that kid is awesome on the right.

Any person that comes on here and uses the Hillsborough Disaster as a means of justifying themselves as a fan is sick.. If that is true then I'm very sorry mate but because someone related to you at Hillsborough died, does not make you any bigger of a fan than anyone else?

No. Hes not sick.
Its your comment above that is sick and offensive.

defoe and torres up front 

Would only take Tevez and possibly Bridge but then again i dont think Bridge is any better than Aurelio when he isn't injured and in good form.