Graphics- Xbox 360
Console- Xbox 360
Controller- Xbox 360
Price- Xbox 360... judging by a quick look on Google.
Games-Not really sure,
Online- PS3 because it's no extra cost.
As a PS3 owner I have to disagree with your very informative post:
Graphics, Xbox360?, Have you not seen GT5P or Drakes Fortune? regardless of weather you like them or not they are the best two looking games out on either platflorm
Consol,l Xbox360? Based on what?? The fact you can (on PS3) browse the web, watch Blu-Ray, have a built in wifi reciver,have backword playability for PS1/PS2 (60gb models only) just to name a few, then you have remote play with PSP!!
Controller, never played on a 360 so cannot comment but this more than anything is based on your own preferance, I am very happy with the PS3 pad, the sixaxis was abit light and flimsy but I have a PS3 dual shock which is excellent so....... Each to there own (does the xbox one need batteries?)
Price, Basic consol yes the Xbox is a cheaper at £159 but that is for the basic system, to make the most of the system you need a HDD/maybe a wireless reciver/wireless controler batteries thats an extra £130 (all based on argos prices and hdd was 20gb) so is it better on price?? no as you still dont have HDMI output or a HD/Blu-Ray player
Games, most titles are both format so you can only really judge exclusives (early ports were better on 360 but most now are pretty identical), so thats faily equal, GoW2 does look pretty awsome but RFOM2 does along with Motorstorm2/Killzone2 so.......
Online Xbox is the more established of the two and is better, yes you have to pay but the benefits it offers over PSN for £26 a year (ebay price) I would would be willing to pay, PSN will have Home but as that has been put back yet again I would say Live wins this one
These are my opinions................
... (and yes i maybe 'slightly' biased but there are fact in there too!)
either way people just have fun and make the most of which one you have!